Published Decisions: (Filings)

By Statute | Alphabetical | Reverse Chronological | Appeal Number | By Citation (1155 records in this collection) Search this collection | Search entire database

Appeal Number Filing Number Date Filed Description

NPDES 15-10

2

5

9

12

15

18

21

24

27

28 04/21/2016 Facsimile Cover Sheet - S. Jaffe et al

26 04/19/2016 Joint Unopposed Invensys Systems Inc. Motion for Leave to Withdraw the Petition and Joint Motion to Dismiss the Proceedings

25 04/06/2016 Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al

23 03/31/2016 Permit Issuer Joint Status Report

22 03/03/2016 Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al

20 03/01/2016 Joint Status Report and Fourth Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time

19 01/11/2016 Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al

17 01/08/2016 Joint Supplemental 3rd Status Report

16 01/07/2016 Facsimile Cover sheet to S. Jaffe et at Order Requiring Supplemental Status Report

14 01/04/2016 Status Report and Third Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time

13 11/05/2015 Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al

11 11/02/2015 Status Report and Second Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time

10 09/16/2015 Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al

8 09/15/2015 Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time

7 09/04/2015 Petition for Review of the Invensys Systems NPDES Permit Issued by EPA Region 1

6 08/06/2015 Facsimile Cover Sheet -- to Seth D. Jaffe et al -- Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review

4 08/03/2015 Permit Issuer Opposition to Motion for Extension of Time

3 07/30/2015 Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe, Esq.

1 07/29/2015 Invensys Systems, Motion for Extension of Time-- Received via FedEx Express Priority Overnight Mail

NPDES 15-11

4

7

9

11

10 01/11/2016 Town of Salisbury Motion for Leave to Withdraw the Petition and Joint Motion to Dismiss the Proceedings

8 12/08/2015 Joint Unopposed Third Motion to Stay the Proceedings

6 11/04/2015 Second Joint Motion to Stay the Proceedings

5 10/13/2015 Joint Status Report

3 09/02/2015 Permit Issuer Joint Motion to Stay the Proceedings

2 08/14/2015 ADR Offer Letter to W. Taylor et al

1 08/13/2015 Town of Salisbury Sewer Commission Petition for Review

1.02 08/13/2015 Attachment 2 -- February 2011 Ammonia Nitrogen Removal Engineering Report Prepared by Weston & Sampson

1.01 08/13/2015 Attachment 1 -- July 13 2011 Administrative Order Document No. 11 012

1.05 08/13/2015 Attachment 5 --May 2 2014 Letter fro D. Dart to N. Harrington Salisbury Town Manager

1.08 08/13/2015 Attachment 8 -- February 10 2015 Comments of Christopher M. Perkins PE Weston & Sampson on Behalf of the Town

1.06 08/13/2015 Attachment 6 --July 31 2014 Scope of Work with Cover Letter to G. Harding EPA and K. Brander MassDEP

1.03 08/13/2015 Attachment 3 -- January 2013 Copper Optimization Engineering Report, Prepared by Weston & Sampson

1.04 08/13/2015 Attachment 4 -- January 2015 Quarterly Progress Report

1.07 08/13/2015 Attachment 7 -- April 14 2015 Letter from D. Dart to N. Harrington

NPDES 15-12

5

9

11

13

17

16 07/07/2016 Petitioner Assented to Motion for Leave to Withdraw its Petition and Joint Motion to Dismiss the Proceedings

15 07/05/2016 Joint 5th Status Report

14 06/03/2016 Fourth Joint Status Report

12 03/29/2016 Third Joint Status Report and Motion to Further Continue the Stay of the Proceedings

10 02/12/2016 Joint Unopposed 3rd For an Extension of Time

8 12/15/2015 Joint Status Report and Motion to Continue the Current Stay of the Proceedings

7 12/08/2015 Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions, Received via email and electronic filing

6 12/08/2015 Filing of Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions, Received via email and electronic filing

4 11/12/2015 Joint Unopposed Motion to stay the Proceedings

3 11/06/2015 ADR Offer Letter to V. Moore et al

1 11/04/2015 Sterling Suffolk Racecourse Petition for Review

2 11/04/2015 Email from V. Moore requesting the Board to delete three duplicate attachments Filing ID PINT A3XQYV that were filed electronically

NPDES 16-01

3

10

12

16

19

22

21 04/05/2017 Motion For Voluntary Dismissal of Petition

20 04/04/2017 Fascimile Cover Sheet - M. Gildea

18 04/03/2017 Status Report and Third Joint Motion for Further Stay of the Proceedings

17 03/22/2017 Facsimile Cover Sheet - B. Corman et at

15 03/21/2017 Status Report and Joint Motion for Further Stay of the Proceedings

14 03/20/2017 Status Report and Joint Motion for Further Stay of the Proceedings

13 02/07/2017 Facsimile Cover Sheet - M. Gildea et al

11 02/06/2017 Status Report and Joint Motion for Further Stay of the Proceedings t

9 12/08/2016 Town Reply to EPA Response to Town's Motion to Stay and Request for Oral Argument

8 12/07/2016 Permit Issuer EPA Region 1's Response to the Town of Bridgewater's Motion for Stay and for an Accelerated Ruling Thereonr

7 12/05/2016 Notice of Appearance, Motion for Stay and For Accelerated Decision, and Request for Oral Argument

6 11/30/2016 Permit Issuer, EPA Region 1's, Reply to the Town of Bridgewater's Opposition to EPA Region 1's Motion to Dismiss the Petition

4 11/22/2016 Facsimile Cover Sheet - M. Gildea et al

5 11/22/2016 The Town of Bridgewater's Opposition to EPA Region 1's Motion to Dismiss the Town's Petition

1.01 11/17/2016 Attachment A Letter from Town of Bridgewater reviewed the Draft NPDES permit

1 11/17/2016 Bridgewater Petition for Review

1.02 11/17/2016 Attachment B NPDES Permit

1.09 11/17/2016 Attachment E Draft Permit

1.05 11/17/2016 Attachment D Comprehensive Wastewater Management Plan with Water Resources

1.1 11/17/2016 Attachment F Fact Sheet

1.03 11/17/2016 Letter to C. Kane, Final NPDES permit issued Part 1 of 2

1.04 11/17/2016 Letter to C. Kane, Final NPDES permit issued Part 2 of 2

1.07 11/17/2016 Attachment D Comprehensive Wastewater Management Plan with Water Resources Cont'd

1.08 11/17/2016 Attachment D Comprehensive Wastewater Management Plan with Water Resources Cont'd

1.06 11/17/2016 Attachment D Comprehensive Wastewater Management Plan with Water Resources Cont'd

2 11/15/2016 EPA Region 1 Motion to Dismiss the Petition as Untimely and to Stay the Filing of the Response to Petition and Certified Index of the Administrative Record

NPDES 17-01

4

5

6

7

8

10

9 10/25/2017 Petitioner 1st Unopposed Buzzards Bay Coalition's Motion to Withdraw its Petition and Dismiss its Appeal

3 06/01/2017 Joint Notice of Intent to Participate in the Alternative Dispute Resolution Program

2 05/18/2017 ADR Offer with enclosure to M. Chertok and C. Dierker

1 05/15/2017 Petitioner, Buzzards Bay Coalition, Petition for Review

NPDES 17-02

4

5

6

7

8

10

9 10/25/2017 Petitioner 1st Motion for Voluntary Dismissal of Petition

3 06/01/2017 Joint Notice of Intent to Participate in ADR

2 05/18/2017 ADR Offer Letter with enclosure to M. J. Connolly and C. Dierker

1 05/15/2017 Petitioner, the Town of Marion, Petition for Review

NPDES 17-03

3

12

14

19

21

22

23

28

33

34

31 11/29/2018 Permit Issuer Respondent EPA Region 6 Reply to Petitioner Memorandum Brief in Opposition to the EPA Motion to Supplement the Administrative RecordBrief

32 11/20/2018 Oral Argument transcript on October 30, 2018

30 11/13/2018 Petitioner Response Brief

29 11/08/2018 Respondent EPA Region 6 Notice of Filing of a Copy of the Final Permit Issued in 2000 for the Ruidoso WWTP and Opposed Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record

27 10/30/2018 Permit Issuer Respondent EPA Region 6 Opposed Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record

25 10/16/2018 Received via Email Permittee City of Ruidoso Downs and Village of Ruidoso will be attending Oral Argument in Person

26 10/16/2018 Received via Email Petitioner will present Oral Argument

24 10/15/2018 Received via Email Notification of Counsel at Oral Argument

20 04/26/2018 Joint Unopposed Motion to Reschedule June 14, 2018 Oral Argument 1st

18 03/05/2018 Petitioner Reply Brief

17 02/14/2018 Letter from Region 6 enclosed four CDs each containing a copy of the Administrative Record.

16 01/18/2018 Permittee Notice of Appearance by the Village of Ruidoso and the City of Ruidoso Downs and Response to Petition for Review

15 01/18/2018 Permit Issuer EPA Region 6's Response Brief to the Petition for Review

13 11/14/2017 Joint Supplement to Joint Motion by all Parties for an EAB Order Establishing a Revised Briefing Schedule and Joint Notice by all Parties of Agreement to Electronic Service Between all Parties

11 11/07/2017 Joint Unopposed Motion 2nd Time By all Parties for an EAB Order Establishing a Revised Briefing Schedule and Joint Notice by all Parties of Agreement to Electronic Service between all Parties

10 10/24/2017 Petitioner Notice of Withdrawal of Filing (Nos. 7 and 8 on Index of Filings)

8 10/24/2017 Duplicate Filing Removed (See Filing #10)

7 10/24/2017 Duplicate Filing Removed (See Filing #10)

9 10/16/2017 Notice of Address of Attorney for Permittees

6 10/12/2017 Petitioner Memorandum Brief in Support of Petition for Review

5 10/10/2017 ADR Offer Letter to E. Kendrick, Esq. Return to Sender, Attempted, Not Known Unable to Forward Return to Sender

4 09/26/2017 ADR Offer Letter to S. Sugarman, D. Gillespie, and E. Kendrick

1 08/22/2017 Petition for Review

2 08/22/2017 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time

NPDES 17-04

5

6

15

16 11/14/2017 Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bostic

17 11/13/2017 Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bailey

13 10/11/2017 Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bailey

14 10/10/2017 Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bostic

12 10/03/2017 Domestic Return Receipt - D. Montgomery

11 10/02/2017 Motion for Reconsideration or Clarification with Attachment and Certification of Service

10 09/28/2017 Domestic Return Receipt - D. Montgomery

7 09/25/2017 J. Bailey Motion for Reconsideration or Clarification

9 09/25/2017 Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bailey

8 09/25/2017 Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bostic

4 09/12/2017 Email Correspondence between Jill Bailey and Clerk of the Board from August 29, 2017 to September 12, 2017

2 09/06/2017 J. Bailey Petition for Review

1 09/05/2017 Petition for Review Cover Letter

3 09/05/2017 Petition for Review Certificate of Service

NPDES 17-05

3

5

10

11

17

22

21 04/04/2018 Domestic Return Receipt - L. Lovejoy

19 03/27/2018 Domestic Return Receipt - S. DeRoma et al

20 03/27/2018 Domestic Return Receipt - J. Block

18 02/28/2018 Oral Argument Transcript on February 22, 2018

16 02/27/2018 Petitioner Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety Post-Argument Submission Pursuant to 40 C.F.R. Section 124.2 and 124.5(b)

15 02/27/2018 Permittees Response to Request from Oral Argument received via FedEx.and email

14 02/06/2018 Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety Notice of Intent to Appear and Present Oral Argument

13 02/05/2018 Permit Issuer Notice Designation of Attorney Presenting Oral Argument

12 02/02/2018 Counsel will be Present for Oral Argument

9 11/03/2017 Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety Reply Submission Pursuant to 40 C.F.R. Section 124.2 and 124.5(b)

8 10/18/2017 EPA Response to Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety's Informal Appeal of EPA's Denial of Request to Terminate Permit Authorization

7 10/16/2017 Response to Order for Additional Briefing dated September 21, 2017

6 09/27/2017 ADR Offer Letter to J. Block et al with enclosure

4 09/22/2017 Facsimile - Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time and Order Granting Extension of Time to File Response

2 09/18/2017 Letter to W. Honker and J. Payne Requesting a Response that Addresses the Petitioner Petition for Review

1 09/14/2017 Petitioner Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety Petition for Review

NPDES 17-06

6

10

9 01/09/2018 Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st To Dismiss

8 01/09/2018 Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal

7 10/30/2017 Facsimile Cover Sheet - M. Nykiel et al

5 10/26/2017 EPA Region 10's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief

4 10/25/2017 Permit Issuer Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions

3 10/25/2017 ADR Offer Letter to M. Nykiel and A. Stern

2 10/10/2017 Received via Federal Express Certificate of Service confirming service by Federal Express Mail to the Regional Administrator for EPA Region 10 and the Permit Applicant

1 10/06/2017 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 17-07

4

6

8

10 01/23/2018 Domestic Return Receipt - M. Gorski

9 01/23/2018 Domestic Return Receipt - G. Morand

7 12/28/2017 Joint Unopposed To Dismiss

5 12/11/2017 Joint 1st Status Report

3 11/01/2017 Permit Issuer Joint Unopposed 1st Motion To Stay

2 10/19/2017 ADR Offer Letter to G. Morand, C. Dierker, and M. Gorski

1 10/16/2017 Barnhardt Manufacturing Company Petition for Review

NPDES 17-08

8

11

14

16

18

20

5.02 11/29/2019 U.S. EPA Region 1 Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions

19 05/04/2018 Motion for Voluntary Dismissal of Petition for Review received via Electronic Filing and Overnight Mail

17 04/18/2018 Joint 5th MotionTo Continue Stay

15 03/28/2018 Joint 4th To Continue Stay

13 03/15/2018 Third Joint MotionTo Continue Stay

12 03/08/2018 Fourth Joint Status Report

10 02/09/2018 Joint 3rd Status Report

9 02/08/2018 Joint 3rd Status Report

7 01/08/2018 Joint 2nd Status Report and Motion to Continue the Stay

6 12/08/2017 First Joint Status Report and Acknowledgement of Consent to Electronic Service

5 11/29/2017 Permit Issuer Notice Uncontested and Severable Conditions Cover Letter and Certificate of Service

4 11/13/2017 Order Granting Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings

3 11/07/2017 Joint 1st Motion To Stay The Proceedings

2 10/30/2017 ADR Offer Letter to W. Taylor et al

1 10/27/2017 Petitioner Town of Fairhaven Petition for Review

NPDES 18-01

6

9

16

15 10/24/2018 Petitioner Reply Brief

14 09/24/2018 Idaho Department of Environmental Quality Response to Idaho Conservation League Petition for Review

13 09/24/2018 Permit Issuer EPA Region 10 Excerpts of the Administrative Record

12 09/24/2018 Permit Issuer EPA Region 10 Certification and Index to the Administrative Record

11 09/24/2018 Permit Issuer Region 10 Response Brief

10 08/30/2018 Certificate of Service to Idaho Department of Environmental Quality of Order Granting Extension of Time

8 08/17/2018 ICLs Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply Brief

7 08/06/2018 Permit Issuer Notice Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions

5 07/30/2018 EPA Region 10s Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief

4 07/27/2018 Idaho Department of Environmental Quality's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief

3 07/27/2018 Idaho Department of Environmental Quality's Notice of Appearance

2 07/25/2018 ADR Offer Letter

1 07/12/2018 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 18-02

4

6

13

21

25

28

29

27 12/19/2018 Region IX Motion to Dismiss

26 12/19/2018 Region IX Notice of Permit Withdrawal

24 11/02/2018 Appellants Response to Order for Clarification

23 11/02/2018 Region IXs Response to Order Directing Parties to Provide Further Clarification

22 11/02/2018 Arizona Public Serivce Company's Response to Order Directing Parties to Provide Further Clarification

20 10/23/2018 Permit Issuer Reply Brief Attachments with Certificate of Service

19 10/22/2018 Permit Issuer Reply Brief

18 10/22/2018 Arizona Public Service Company's Reply in Support of Region IX's Motion to Partially Dismiss Petition for Review; Motion to Establish Revised Briefing Schedule

17 10/17/2018 Petitioner Amended Notice of Appearance

16 10/17/2018 Petitioner Response Brief

15 10/16/2018 Petitioner Notice of Appearance

14 10/16/2018 Petitioner Notice of Appearance

12 10/10/2018 Permittee Notice APS's Response to Region IX's Motion to Partially Dismiss Petition for Review; Motion to Establish Revised Briefing Schedule

11 10/10/2018 Permittee Notice of Appearance

10 10/09/2018 Permit Issuer Opposed Other

9 10/09/2018 Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal and Revised Notice of Stayed Provisions

8 08/28/2018 Permit Issuer Notice Stay of Permit Pending Appeal

7 08/27/2018 Permit Issuer Notice Declining ADR

5 08/09/2018 Region 9 Supplement to its Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Responses and Replies

3 08/01/2018 Permit Issuer Unopposed For Extension of Time to File Responses and Replies

2 07/26/2018 ADR Offer Letter

1 07/16/2018 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 18-03

4

9

13

12 10/19/2018 Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st To Dismiss

11 10/15/2018 Permit Issuer 3rd Status Report

10 10/15/2018 Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal

8 09/11/2018 Joint 1st Status Report

7 08/28/2018 Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested Permit Conditions

6 08/27/2018 Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested Permit Conditions

5 08/16/2018 Joint Acknowledgement of Consent to Service by Electronic Mail

3 08/12/2018 Joint Motion to Stay the Proceedings

2 08/02/2018 ADR Offer Letter

1 07/18/2018 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 18-04

5

7

9 10/29/2018 Domestic Return Receipt K. Walker

8 10/24/2018 Domestic Return Receipt M. Nykiel

6 10/10/2018 Permit Issuer EPA Region 10 Motion to Dismiss

4 08/20/2018 Joint Motion for Extension of Time to File Response and Reply Brief

3 08/14/2018 Permit Issuer Notice Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions

2 08/03/2018 ADR Offer Letter

1 07/26/2018 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 19-01

4

6

8

10

13

12 01/21/2020 Joint Unopposed 1st To Dismiss

11 01/13/2020 Joint 3rd Status Report

9 12/09/2019 Joint Status Report and Motion Requesting Further Stay of Proceedings

7 11/01/2019 Joint Status Report

5 08/15/2019 Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings

3 08/05/2019 Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions

2 07/26/2019 Request for Replacement of Attachment 6 of the Petition for Review

1 07/22/2019 Petitioner Hecla Limited Lucky Friday Mine Petition for Review

NPDES 19-02

4

6

5 09/27/2019 EPA Reguon 10 Motion for Voluntary Remand

3 08/19/2019 EPA Region 10 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief

2 08/12/2019 Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions

1 07/25/2019 Petitioner City of Nezperce Petition for Review

NPDES 19-03

4

9

15

19

18 03/20/2020 February 20 2020 Oral Argument Transcript

17 01/16/2020 Permit Issuer Notice Regarding Oral Argument

16 01/10/2020 Respondent EPA's Surreply

14 01/06/2020 Permit Issuer EPA Motion for Leave to File surreply

13 12/27/2019 Petitioner Notice Ltr to EAB re Corrected Word Limitation

12 12/23/2019 Corrected Reply Brief

11 12/23/2019 Petitioner Reply Brief

10 12/20/2019 City of Lowell's Notice Regarding Oral Argument

8 12/10/2019 Permit Issuer Notice Certified Index to the Administrative Record

7 12/10/2019 Permit Issuer Rspondent EPA Region 1 Response to the Petition for ReviewResponse Brief

6 12/10/2019 Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1 Cover Letter

5 12/10/2019 Joint Filing -- EPA & City of Lowell Consent to Service VIA Electronic Mail

3 11/19/2019 Permit Issuer EPA Motion for Extension of Time

2 11/08/2019 Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions

1 10/24/2019 City of Lowell Massachusetts Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 19-04

4

7

9

12

14

13 04/27/2020 City of Haverhill Massachusetts Assented to Request for Dismissal of Petition

11 04/07/2020 Joint Status Report Notice of Partial Withdrawal and Fourth Motion to Stay the Proceedings

10 04/07/2020 Permit Issuer Notice Cover Letter for Status Report, Partial Withdrawal, and Fourth Motion to Stay

8 02/21/2020 Joint Status Report and Third Motion to Stay the Proceedings

6 01/07/2020 Joint Unopposed 2nd For an Extension of Time

5 01/07/2020 Permit Issuer Notice Cover Letter for Status Report and Motion

3 11/14/2019 Joint Motion To Stay The Proceedings

2 11/08/2019 Permit Issuer Notice Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions

1 10/25/2019 City of Haverhill Petition for Review

NPDES 19-05

5

8

10

12

11 04/03/2020 Greater Lawrence Sanitary District Assented to Request for Dismissal of Petition

9 02/21/2020 Joint Status Report and Third Motion to Stay the Proceedings

7 01/07/2020 Joint Unopposed 2nd For an Extension of Time

6 01/07/2020 Permit Issuer Notice Cover Letter for Status Report and Motion

4 11/14/2019 Joint Motion To Stay The Proceedings

3 11/08/2019 Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions

2 10/29/2019 Petitioner Notice Errata Sheet

1 10/25/2019 Greater Lawrence Sanitary District Petition for Review

NPDES 19-06

2

4

15

20

23

29

31

36

39

40

38 09/30/2020 September 3 2020 Oral Argument Transcript

37 08/19/2020 Region 9 Response to Order Requiring Documents To Be Included In The Administrative Record

35 07/31/2020 Amicus Navajo Transitional Energy Company LLC Notice Regarding Oral Argument

34 07/31/2020 Region 9 Notice Regarding Oral Argument

33 07/31/2020 Arizona Public Service Company's Notice Regarding Oral Argument

32 07/29/2020 Petitioner Notice Regarding Oral Argumement

30 02/12/2020 Permittee Reply Brief

28 01/28/2020 Permittee Arizona Public Service Company Reply to Petitioners Opposition to Motion for Leave to File a Surreply or in the Alternative to Strike all New Issues and Arguments in Petitioners Reply

27 01/24/2020 Petitioner Response Brief

26 01/17/2020 Permittee Opposed 1st For Leave to File A Surreply or in the Alternative to Strike all New Issues and Arguments in Petitioners Reply

25 01/16/2020 Permit Issuer Notice Revised Certified Administrative Record Index

24 01/13/2020 Petitioner Consolidated Reply Brief to EPA and APS Response Briefs and to NTEC Amicus Brief

22 01/02/2020 Navajo Transitional Energy Company LLC Amicus Brief

21 01/02/2020 Amicus Notice of Appearance

19 12/30/2019 Petitioner Unopposed Motion to Strike Administrative Record Document Number 30

18 12/30/2019 Petitioner Unopposed 1st For an Extension of Time

17 12/30/2019 Received via Fax Petitioners Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Rely Brief

16 12/23/2019 Permit Issuer Corrected Table of Attachments

14 12/20/2019 Corrected Certificate of Service

13 12/19/2019 Attachment 8 to APS Response to Petition for Review

12 12/18/2019 Permit Issuer Certificate of Service

11 12/18/2019 Permit Issuer Response Brief

10 12/18/2019 Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st Other

9 12/18/2019 Attachments 20 through 26 for APS Response to Petition for Review

8 12/18/2019 Arizona Public Service Company's Response to Petition for Review

6 11/25/2019 Permit Issuer Notice of Stay

5 11/18/2019 Notice of Appearance By Arizona Public Service Company

3 11/15/2019 Motion for Leave to Exceed Word Limitation

1 11/01/2019 Dine Citizens Against Ruining the Environment, San Juan Citizen Alliance, Amigos Bravos, Center for Biological Diversity and Sierra Club Petition for Review

NPDES 19-07

3

2 01/16/2020 Region IX Motion to Dismiss

1 12/20/2019 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 20-01

4

10

14

18

22

25

27

33

34

32 11/13/2020 Oral Argument Transcript held on October 8, 2020

31 09/11/2020 Petitioner Notice Regarding Oral Argument

30 09/11/2020 Petitioner Reply Brief

29 09/10/2020 Region 9 Notice Regarding Oral Argument

28 08/20/2020 Notice of Appearance of Richard S. Davis and Andrew C. Silton

26 08/14/2020 San Francisco's Unopposed Motion for Schedule Modification

24 07/30/2020 San Francisco's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time

23 07/23/2020 Permit Issuer Region 9 Response to San Francisco Supplement to Petition for Review

20 06/30/2020 Joint Motion for Extension of Time

21 06/30/2020 Supplement to Petition for Review of City and County of San Francisco's Oceanside Wastewater Treatment Plants NPDES Permit Issued by EPA Region 9

19 06/22/2020 Permit Issuer Notice of Errata June 22, 2020

17 06/15/2020 City and County of San Francisco Reply in Support of Motion for Partial Reconsideration or in the Alternative Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review

16 06/08/2020 Permit Issuer Region 9 Response to Motion for Partial Reconsideration or, in the Alternative, Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review

15 05/21/2020 City and County of San Francisco Motion for Partial Reconsideration or in the Alternative Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review

13 04/16/2020 City and County of San Francisco Reply in Support of Motion to Stay Contested Permit Conditions Pending Appeal or in the Alternative Motion to Remand Notice of Stayed Contested Permit Conditions and Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review

12 04/15/2020 City and County of San Francisco Reply Brief in Support of Petition for Review of San Francisco Oceanside Wastewater Treatment Plants NPDES Permit Issued by EPA Region 9

11 04/15/2020 Brief of Amici Curiae National Association of Clean Water Agencies and California Association of Sanitation Ageencies in Support of Petitioner

9 03/18/2020 Petitioner Unopposed Motion For Extension of Time

8 03/16/2020 Permit Issuer Region 9 Response to Motion to Stay Contested Permit Conditiions Pending Appeal or in the Alternative Motion to Remand Notice of Stayed Contested Permit Conditions and Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review

7 02/28/2020 Permit Issuer Notice Certified Administrative Record Index

6 02/28/2020 EPA Region 9 Response to San Francisco Petition for Review of Oceanside NPDES Permit

5 02/28/2020 City and County of San Francisco Motion to Stay Contested Permit Conditions Pending Appeal or in the Alternative Motion to Remand Notice of Stayed Contested Permit Conditions and Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review

3 02/10/2020 Joint Motion for Extension of Time

2 02/07/2020 Permit Issuer Notice of Stay

1 01/13/2020 Petitioner City and County of San Francisco Petition for Review

NPDES 20-02

3

7

6 03/16/2020 EPA Reply to Incorporated County of Los Alamos Response to Motion to Dismiss For Lack of Jurisdiction or in the Alternative Motion for Extension of Time

5 03/05/2020 Incorporated County of Los Alamos New Mexico Response to Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction or in the Alternative Motion for Extension of Time

4 03/02/2020 Petitioner Notice of Appearance

2 02/14/2020 Permit Issuer Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction, or in the Alternative Motion for Extension of Time

1 01/17/2020 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 20-03

3

10

13

15

14 11/23/2020 HOLTEC Decommissioning International LLC and HOLTEC Pilgrim LLC Assented to Request for Dismissal of Petition

12 10/15/2020 Joint 4th Status Report and Motion to Extend Stay

11 09/08/2020 Joint 3rd Status Report

9 07/17/2020 Joint Motion to Extend Stay of Proceedings

8 07/08/2020 Motion For Withdrawal of Entergy As Petitioner

7 06/30/2020 Motion for Partial Withdrawal of Petition for Review

6 06/29/2020 Joint 2nd Status Report

4 05/12/2020 Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions

2 03/26/2020 Joint Motion For Stay of the Proceedings

1 03/06/2020 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 20-04

2

6

5 05/21/2020 Permit Issuer Region 9 Motion to Dismiss

4 05/21/2020 Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal of Permit and Notice of Effective Date

3 04/27/2020 Permittee Petition for Review of Starkist Samoa Co. NPDES AS0000019

1 03/18/2020 Motion with Consent for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review

NPDES 20-05

3

15

18

22

25

26

31

33

35

37

39

44

43 06/16/2021 EPA Region 1 Reply to Petitioners’ Responses to EPA’s Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Re Calendaring of Oral Argument

42 06/11/2021 Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Recalendaring of Oral Argument NPDES Appeals N. 20-05 20-06

41 06/11/2021 Response of Petitioners Sierra Club and Conservation Law Foundation to EPA Region 1 Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Recalendaring of Oral Argument NPDES Appeal No 20 05

40 06/04/2021 EPA Region 1 Motion for Voluntary Remand and Partial Re Calendaring for Oral Argument Granite Shore Power Merrimack LLC NPDES Appeals Nos 20-05 and 20-06

38 04/26/2021 EPA Region 1 Reply to GSP Merrimack LLC Response to the Region Motion for Further Abeyance

36 04/21/2021 Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Further Abeyance

34 04/14/2021 Permit Issuer EPA Region 1 Motion for Further Abeyance

32 02/08/2021 Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Continuance of the Date fo Oral Argument and Abeyance

30 02/03/2021 Permit Issuer Region 1 Motion for Continuance of the Date for Oral Argument and Abeyance

29 01/11/2021 Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1's Notice of Participation

28 01/11/2021 Permittee Notice of Participation

27 01/08/2021 Petitioner Notice of Participation

24 12/04/2020 Region 1 Reply to Petitioners' Opposition to the Region's Motion to Strike Attachments 36 Through 41 to the Petition for Reviewr

23 12/04/2020 Region 1 Surreply

21 11/20/2020 Permit Issuer Motion for Leave to File Surreply

20 11/09/2020 Petitioners' Opposition to EPA Region 1 Motion to Strike

19 11/09/2020 Petitioner Reply Brief

17 10/21/2020 Petitioner Unopposed 2nd For an Extension of Time

16 10/09/2020 Amicus Brief of the N.H. Department of Environmental Services

14 09/30/2020 Consent Motion for Extension of time to Respond to Motion to Strike and to Reply to Response

13 09/25/2020 Permittee Brief

12 09/25/2020 Permit Issuer EPA Region 1 Motion to Strike Petitioners Attachments 36-41 to the Petition for Review

11 09/25/2020 Permit Issuer Response Brief

10 09/25/2020 Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1 Cover Letter

9 09/25/2020 Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1 Certified Administrative Record Index

8 09/25/2020 Permit Issuer Notice Certified Index to the Administrative Record

7 09/01/2020 Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions

6 08/11/2020 Permittee Notice of Appearance by GSP Merrimack LLC

5 07/27/2020 Petition for Review by Sierra Club Conservation Law Foundation Attachments Continued

4 07/27/2020 Petition for Review by Sierra Club Conservation Law Foundation

2 06/15/2020 Consent Motion Regarding Briefing Schedule and Word Limits for Petition for Review, Response, and Replies

1 06/12/2020 Consent Motion Regarding Briefing Schedule and Word Limits for Petition for Review, Response, and Replies

NPDES 20-06

10

12

13

17

19

21

23

25

29

28 06/16/2021 EPA Region 1 Reply to Petitioners’ Responses to EPA’s Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Re-Calendaring of Oral Argument,

27 06/11/2021 Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Recalendaring of Oral Argument NPDES Appeals No 20-05 20-06

26 06/04/2021 EPA Region 1 Motion for Voluntary Remand and Partial Re Calendaring of Oral Argument Granite Shore Power Merrimack LLC NPDES Appeals Nos 20-05 and 20-06

24 04/26/2021 EPA Region 1 Reply to GSP Merrimack LLC Response to the Region Motion for Further Abeyance

22 04/21/2021 Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Further Abeyance

20 04/14/2021 Permit Issuer EPA Region 1 Motion for Further Abeyance

18 02/08/2021 Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Continuance of the Date fo Oral Argument and Abeyance

16 02/03/2021 Region 1 Motion for Continuance of the Date for Oral Argument and Abeyance

15 01/11/2021 Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1's Notice of Participation

14 01/11/2021 Petitioner Notice of Participation

11 11/16/2020 Sur-Reply by EPA Region 1 to the Petition for Review by GSP Merrimack Station

9 11/06/2020 Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st For Leave to File

8 10/26/2020 Petitioner Reply Brief

5 09/25/2020 Permit Issuer Response Brief

4 09/25/2020 Permit Issuer Notice Region 1 Cover Letter to Response to the Petition for Review

7 09/25/2020 Certified Index to the Administrative Record

6 09/25/2020 Certified Index to the Administrative Record

3 09/01/2020 Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions

2 08/11/2020 Petitioner Notice of Entry of Appearance

1 07/27/2020 Petitioner Petition for Review

1 07/27/2020 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 20-07

4

6

26

25

30

32

34

35

40

39 05/07/2021 Oral Argument Transcript Springfield Water and Sewer Comission March 31 2021

38 03/17/2021 Permit Issuer Notice Amended Certified AR Index

37 03/08/2021 Permit Issuer Notice of Participation in Oral Argument

36 03/08/2021 Petitioner Notice Notice of Participation

33 02/17/2021 Springfield Water and Sewer Commission Response to EPA Surreply

31 02/10/2021 Cover Letter and Respondent EPA Surreply

29 02/05/2021 Cover Letter and EPA Motion For Leave to File Surreply

28 01/27/2021 Permittee Reply Brief

27 01/22/2021 Permittee 1st Status Report

24 12/17/2020 Springfield Water and Sewer Commission Motion for Extension of Time

22 12/16/2020 Uncontested and Severable Conditions Letter

21 12/16/2020 Amicus Brief of the Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection

20 12/16/2020 Amicus Brief of Save the Sound, Inc.

23 12/16/2020 Amicus Curiae of the Connecticut River Conservancy in Support of the Permitting Agencies

19 12/11/2020 Permit Issuer Certified Index to the Administrative Record

18 12/11/2020 AR Index

17 12/11/2020 Exhibit EE

16 12/11/2020 Exhibit DD

15 12/11/2020 Exhibit CC

14 12/11/2020 Exhibit BB

13 12/11/2020 Exhibit AA

12 12/11/2020 Exhibit Z

11 12/11/2020 Exhibit Y

10 12/11/2020 Exhibit X

9 12/11/2020 Exhibit W

8 12/11/2020 EPA Region 1 Response to the Petition for Review

7 12/11/2020 EPA Region 1 Cover Letter

5 11/20/2020 Amicus Unopposed 1st Motion For an Extension of Time

3 11/09/2020 Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st Motion For an Extension of Time

2 11/09/2020 Permit Issuer Cover Letter for Unopposed First Motion for Extension of Time

1 10/30/2020 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 20-08

3

7

9

11

13

15

16

20

21

19 02/07/2022 Ocean Era, Inc. Appeal Nos. NPDES 20-08, 20-09 Oral Argument Transcript

18 11/01/2021 Petitioner Notice Notice of Participation, Petitioner Friends of Animals, Oral Argument, Ocean Era, Inc. NPDES 20-08

17 10/21/2021 Notice of Participation Region 4, Oral Argument, Ocean Era, Inc. NPDES 20-08

12 05/28/2021 Status Report Ocean Era Inc NPDES Appeal No 20-08

10 03/22/2021 Permit Issuer Unopposed To Stay

8 02/01/2021 Petitioner Reply Brief

6 12/22/2020 Friends of Animals Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time

5 12/18/2020 EPA Region 4s Response to Petition for Review

4 12/18/2020 Certification of Index to the Administrative Record

2 11/16/2020 Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st For an Extension of Time

1 10/30/2020 Petitioner Friends of Animals Petition for Review

NPDES 20-09

3

7

9

11

13

14

18

19

17 02/07/2022 Ocean Era, Inc. Appeal Nos. NPDES 20-08 20-09 Oral Argument Transcript

16 11/01/2021 Petitioner Center for Food Safety Notice of Participation Oral Argument Ocean Era Inc. NPDES Appeal Nos. 20-08 and 20-09.

15 10/21/2021 Notice of Participation Region 4, Oral Argument, Ocean Era, Inc. NPDES 20-09

12 05/28/2021 Status Report Ocean Era Inc NPDES Appeal No 20 09

10 03/22/2021 Permit Issuer Unopposed To Stay

8 02/01/2021 Reply to Response to Petition for Review

6 12/18/2020 EPA Region 4s Response to Petition for Review

5 12/18/2020 Permit Issuer Notice Certified Administrative Record Index

4 12/18/2020 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time

2 11/16/2020 Permit Issuer 1st Unopposed Motion For an Extension of Time

1 10/30/2020 Petitioner Center for Food Safety Petition for Review

NPDES 21-01

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

17

16 09/27/2021 Six Status Report and Unopposed Motion to Dismiss Wulf Cattle Depot NPDES 21-01

15 09/03/2021 Permit Issuer Notice Notice of Filing of Final NPDES Permit Issued to Wulf Cattle Depot and Related Documents

13 08/27/2021 Fifth Status Report and Unopposed Motion for Further Stay of Proceedings, Wulf Cattle Depot, NPDES Appeal No. 21--01

11 08/10/2021 Fourth Status Report and Unopposed Motion for Further Stay of Procedings Wulf Cattle Depot NPDES Appeal No. 21-01

9 07/12/2021 Third Status Report and Unopposed Motion for Further Stay of Proceedings Wulf Cattle Depot NPDES Appeal No. 20-01

7 06/25/2021 Second Status Report and Motion for Further Stay of Proceedings Wulf Cattle Depot NPDES Appeal No 21-01

5 05/17/2021 Status Report and Unopposed Motion for Further Stay of Proceedings

3 03/23/2021 Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st To Stay

1 02/19/2021 Notice of Appeal and Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Appeal Brief

NPDES 21-02

2

1 08/13/2021 Third-Party Appeal of NPDES Permit TN0070661

NPDES 21-03

2

5

13

16

18

22

25

24 05/03/2022 City of Keene Appeal No. NPDES 21-03 Oral Argument Transcript

23 04/01/2022 Cover Letter for Notice Second Amended A.R. Index

21 03/22/2022 City of Keene NH Notice of Participation

20 03/21/2022 EPA Region 1's Notice of Participation City of Keene Oral Argument

19 03/03/2022 Cover Letter for Amended AR Index City of Keene NPDES 21-03

17 02/02/2022 EPA Region 1's Surreply City of Keene, NPDES Appeal No. 21-03 Cover Letter

15 01/31/2022 EPA Region 1's Reply to Petitioner Opposition to the Region Motion for Leave to File Surreply City of Keene NPDESAppeal No. 21-03

14 01/25/2022 Petitioner City of Keene Objection to EPA Surreply

12 01/21/2022 Permit Issuer Opposed 1st For Leave to File

11 01/06/2022 Petitioner Reply Brief

10 12/16/2021 Revised Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions

9 12/15/2021 Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions

8 12/15/2021 Region 1's Response Cover Letterr

7 12/15/2021 Certified Index to the Administrative Record

6 12/15/2021 EPA Region 1's Response to the Petition for Review

4 12/10/2021 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply Brief City of Keene NPDES Appeal No. 21-03

3 11/15/2021 Petition for Review City of Keene

1 09/24/2021 Notice of Appeal NPDES Permit No. NH-0100790 Keene Wastewater Treatment Plant

NPDES 21-04

4

3 12/15/2021 Petitioners Motion to Dismiss Petition for Review

2 12/15/2021 Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions and Withdrawal

1 11/24/2021 City of Marlborough, Massachusetts Westerly Wastewater Treatment Facility NPDES Permit No. MA0100480 Petition for Review

NPDES 22-01

1

5

7

16

18

18 09/14/2022 Permit Issuer Notice of Appearance

17 09/01/2022 EPA Response to Order Requesting Clarification

15 08/23/2022 Permit Applicant's Reply in Support of Motion for Leave to File Surresponse NPDES Appeal No. 22-01

14 08/16/2022 Petitioner's Response to LANL's Motion to File a Surresponse

13 08/02/2022 Permit Applicant's Motion for Leave to File Surresponse

12 07/27/2022 Reply Brief on Petition for Review under 40 C.F.R. 124.19 NPDES Appeal No. 22-01

11 07/08/2022 Certificate of Service Certified Index to the Administrative Record NPDES Appeal No. 22-01

10 07/07/2022 EPA Region 6's Response to Petition for Review

9 07/01/2022 Permit Applicant's Response to Petition for Review US DOE and Triad National Security, LLC

8 06/28/2022 Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions

6 05/23/2022 Notice of Appearance for US Dept. of Energy National Nuclear Security Administration

4 05/19/2022 EPA Region 6 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time

3 05/09/2022 Petitioner Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety Petition for Review (4 additional attachments)

2 05/03/2022 Notice of Appearance for Triad National Security LLC

NPDES 22-02

3

6

7

9

12

11 05/05/2023 Notice of Withdrawal of Petition for Review

10 04/27/2023 Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal

8 01/27/2023 Joint Motion for Extension of Stay

5 10/12/2022 Joint Notification of Agreement to Participate in the Alternative Dispute Resolution Program

4 10/07/2022 Permit Issuer Notice Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions City of Portsmouth NPDES 22-02

2 10/05/2022 Permit Issuer Unopposed Motion for an Extension of Time City of Portsmouth NPDES 22-02

1 09/07/2022 Petitioner Petition for Review City of Portsmouth NPDES 22-02

NPDES 23-01

5

7

8

10

11

12

13

15

14 03/28/2024 Notice of Withdrawal of Petition for Review

9 07/27/2023 Permit Issuer Notice Withdrawal of Certain Permit Provisions

6 05/24/2023 Permit Issuer Notice Notice of Uncontested & Severable Permit Conditions

4 05/04/2023 Joint Notification of Agreement to Participate In The Alternative Dispute Resolution Program

3 04/25/2023 ADR Offer Letter with Enclosure to J. J. Steinkraus, et al

2 04/21/2023 Board Correspondence Clarifying Aspect of City of Rochester’s Submission.

1 04/19/2023 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 23-02

5

6

7

8

9

10

12

11 04/08/2024 Motion to Dismiss Petition for Review

4 07/12/2023 Joint Notice Joint Notification of Agreement to Participate in ADR Program & Joint Motion re Briefing Schedule

3 07/07/2023 Notice of Appearance by Granite Shore Schiller, LLC

2 06/29/2023 ADR Letter Offer with Enclosure to Sarah Krame, et al.

1 06/16/2023 Granite Shore Power Schiller LLC Petition for Review

NPDES 23-03

4

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

16

18

17 07/30/2025 Joint Motion To Dismiss

15 03/17/2025 Joint Motion to Extend Stay of Appeal

14 01/23/2025 Joint Motion To Extend Stay of Appeal

5 11/01/2023 Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions - Massachusetts Port Authority

3 09/29/2023 Joint Notice Joint Notification of Interest in Participating in the ADR Program

2 09/28/2023
Notice of Interest in Participating in the Alternative Dispute Resolution Program and Motion to Stay Filing of the Response to Petition and Production of the Administrative Record - Massachusetts Port Auhtority

1 09/25/2023 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 23-04

5

10

12

13

11 01/11/2024 Petitioner Reply Brief

9 12/19/2023 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time

7 12/13/2023 Permittee Response Brief

8 12/13/2023 Permit Issuer Response Brief

6 11/29/2023 Notice of Appearance for U.S. DOE National Nuclear Security Administration

4 11/15/2023 Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions

3 11/08/2023 Unopposed Motion For Extension of Time

2 11/07/2023 Petitioner Notice of Appearance

1 10/30/2023 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 23-05

4

3 12/12/2023 EPA Region 1's Motion to Dismiss Petition for Review as Moot

2 12/07/2023 Notice of Withdrawal and Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions

1 11/17/2023 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 24-01

2

3

6

9

10

12

11 08/22/2024 Notice of Dismissal for the City of Holyoke

8 04/02/2024 Notice of Uncontested & Severable Permit Conditions

7 04/01/2024 Notification of Agreement to Participate in the Alternative Dispute Resolution Program

5 03/18/2024 ADR Letter Offer with Enclosure to Joshua Garcia, et al.

4 03/13/2024 EPA Region 1's Motion to Clarify the Region's Filing Deadline

1 02/29/2024 Petition for Review of City of Holyoke Water Pollution Control Facility NPDES Permit Issued by Region 1

NPDES 24-02

9

14

12 11/06/2024 Permit Motion to Dismiss

13 11/06/2024 Agency Counsel Notification of Withdrawn Permits

10 09/30/2024 Domestic Return Receipt NPDES 24-02

11 09/30/2024 Domestic Return Receipt NPDES 24-03

8 09/19/2024 Permittee Notice of Appearance (NPDES 24-03)

7 09/19/2024 Permit Issuer Notification of Stayed Conditions (NPDES 24-03)

6 09/19/2024 Permit Issuer Notification of Stayed Conditions (NPDES 24-02)

5 09/19/2024 Joint Motion to Consolidate Petitions for Review and for Extension of Time

3 09/12/2024 ADR Offer Letter with Enclosure to Tulalip Tribes of Wastewater Treatment Plant (NPDES 24-02)

4 09/12/2024 ADR Offer Letter with Enclosure to Lummi Tribal Sewer and Water District (NPDES 24-03)

2 09/09/2024 Petition for Review (NPDES 24-03)

1 09/07/2024 Petition for Review (NPDES 24-02)

NPDES 25-01

2

5

8

15

14 10/10/2025 EPA Region 4's Reply in Support of Motion for Leave to File a Corrected Administrative Record Index

13 10/06/2025 Petitioners' Opposition to EPA Region IV's Motion for Leave To File A Corrected Administrative Record Index

12 09/22/2025 Permit Issuer Motion For Leave to File a Sur-Reply

11 09/22/2025 Permit Issuer Motion for Leave to File a Corrected Administrative Record Index

10 09/22/2025 Permit Issuer Notice Notice of Errata - correcting previous Cert of Service document

9 09/12/2025 Petitioners' Reply to EPA Regioin IV's Combined Response to Petitions for Review

7 08/20/2025 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply

6 08/15/2025 EPA Region 4's Combined Response to Petitions for Review and Request for Expedited Consideration

4 06/25/2025 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time and Authorization to File a Consolidated Response

3 06/14/2025 Petitioner Petition for Review

1 06/12/2025 Petitioner New Appeal: Expedited Motion for Leave to Exceed Word Limitation on EAB Appeal

NPDES 25-02

3

6

13

12 10/10/2025 EPA Region 4's Reply in Support of Motion for Leave to File a Corrected Administrative Record Index

11 10/07/2025 Friends of Animals' Response In Opposition To EPA Region 4's Motion For Leave To File A Corrected Administrative Record Index

10 09/22/2025 Permit Issuer Motion for Leave to File a Sur-Reply

9 09/22/2025 Permit Issuer Motion for Leave to File a Corrected Administrative Record Index

8 09/22/2025 Permit Issuer Notice Notice of Errata correcting previously filed Cert of Service

7 09/12/2025 Friends of Animals' Reply iin Support of its Petition for Review

5 08/19/2025 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply

4 08/15/2025 EPA Region 4's Combined Response to Petitions for Review and Request for Expedited Consideration

2 06/25/2025 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time and Authorization to File a Consolidated Response

1 06/16/2025 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 25-03

3

2 12/01/2025 Region 9's MotionTo Dismiss Petition

1 10/30/2025 Petition for Review

NPDES 25-04

4

7

9

17

16 03/16/2026 Conservation Law Foundation's Reply Brief in Support of Petition for Review

15 02/27/2026 EPA Region 1's Reply to CLF's Objection to EPA Region 1's Motion to Strike

14 02/17/2026 Conservation Law Foundation's Objection to EPA Region 1's Motion to Strike

13 01/30/2026 Response of the City of Manchester, New Hampshire to Conservation Law Foundation's Petition for Review of the City of Manchester Wastewater Treatment Facility and 15 Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) Outfalls NPDES Permit Issued by Region 1

12 01/30/2026 EPA Region 1's Motion to Strike

11 01/30/2026 Certified Administrative Record Index

10 01/30/2026 EPA Region 1's Response To Petition for Review

8 01/14/2026 Petitioner Motion for an Extension of Time

6 12/26/2025 Motion by the City of Manchester for Extension of Time to File A Response to CLF's Petition

5 12/26/2025 Notice of Appearance for City of Manchester

3 12/12/2025 Region 1 Motion For an Extension of Time

2 12/12/2025 Petitioner Notice Notice of Errata (Attachment 1 Corrected Certificate of Service)

1 12/03/2025 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 25-05

3

7

11

12

14

13 03/27/2026 Permit Issuer 2nd Status Report

10 02/10/2026 Joint 1st Status Report

9 02/09/2026 Conservation Law Foundation's Reply to EPA Region 1's and the City of Manchester's Responses to CLF's Motion for Leave to Intervene or, in the Alternative, to Consolidate Dockets

8 01/29/2026 Objection by the City of Manchester, New Hampshire to Conservation Law Foundation's Motion for Leave to Intervene or, in the Alternative, to Consolidate Dockets

6 01/21/2026 EPA Region 1's Opposition to the Motion for Leave to Intervene, or in the Alternative to Consolidate Dockets

5 01/20/2026 Motion of the City of Manchester for an Order Confirming Stay of Appeal Deadlines and to Defer Ruling Upon CLF's Intervention Motion Due to Stay of Appeals Deadlines

4 01/07/2026 Motion for Leave to Intervene or, in the Alternative, to Consolidate Dockets

2 12/19/2025 Motion For Stay of the Proceedings

1 12/03/2025 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 26-01

2

4

7

6 03/20/2026 EPA R6's Unopposed Motion For an Extension of Time

5 02/23/2026 Appellate Brief of the Albuquerque Bernalillo County Water Utility Authority

3 01/16/2026 Petitioner's Motion to Stay Permit Limitations for Total Dissolved Solids

1 01/05/2026 Petitioner Notice of Appeal and Attached Motion for Extension of Time

NPDES 26-02

3

5

6 03/26/2026 Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions

4 03/12/2026 Joint Status Report and Motion to Extend Stay

2 01/22/2026 Permit Issuer Motion for Stay of the Proceedings

1 01/13/2026 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 26-03

3

5

4 03/19/2026 Joint Status Report and Motion to Extend Stay of Appeal

2 01/28/2026 Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st To Stay

1 01/21/2026 Petitioner Petition for Review

NPDES 91-23

0

NPDES 91-25

1

NPDES 92-20

1

NPDES 92-23

1

NPDES 93-2

1

NPDES 93-3

1

NPDES 97-3

1

1

NPDES 99-2

1

NPDES (08-06)

5

8

12

19 05/09/2008 Domestic Return Receipt (HARD COPY ONLY)

18 05/08/2008 Returned -- Address Unknown -- Order Denying Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (HARD COPY ONLY)

17 05/05/2008 Domestic Return Receipt -- (HARD COPY ONLY)

16 05/02/2008 Certrified Mail Returned --- Attempted Not Known -- Order Granting Region's Motion for Extension (HARD COPY ONLY)

14 04/28/2008 Domestic Return Receipt (HARD COPY ONLY)

15 04/28/2008 Returned -- (Attempted - Not Know Unable to Forward) Order Denying Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (HARD COPY ONLY)

13 04/24/2008 Facsimile Cover Sheet -- to Jeffrey Stant et al -- Order Denying Extension of Time to File Petition for Review

11 04/23/2008 Domestic Return Receipt (HARD COPY ONLY)

10 04/18/2008 EPA Region 9's Response to Order Requesting Region's Position on Extension

9 04/17/2008 Facsimile Cover Sheet - Jeffrey Stant et al. -- Order Granting Region's Motion for Extension

7 04/16/2008 EPA Region IX's Motion for Extension of Time to File Response to Order Requesting Region's Position on Extension

6 04/15/2008 Facsimile Cover Sheet -- Jeffrey Stant et al. -- Order Requesting Region's Position on Extension

4 04/14/2008 Original -- Request for two week extension of time (HARD COPY ONLY)

3 04/14/2008 Original -- Request for two week extension (HARD COPY ONLY)

2 04/11/2008 Received via CDX Electronic -- Extension of time to file Petition for Review

1 04/10/2008 Received via CDX Electronic - Motion Requesting Extension of Time to file Petition for Review

NPDES (08-24)

2

3 10/30/2008 Facsimile Cover Sheet -- Susan A. Bernstein -- Order Denying Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review

1 10/29/2008 Fax -- Motion for Extension to File Petition for Appeal and File Brief

NSR 16-01

3

14

15 09/16/2016 Domestic Return Receipt - S. Dolan

13 07/15/2016 Motion of Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and Power District to Strike Petitioner Supplemental Brief, or, Alternatively, Motion for Leave to File a Sur Reply

12 07/13/2016 Region 9 response to EAB request for comments submitted on draft permit

11 07/07/2016 Petitioner -- Summary of Environmental Justice Policy

10 06/27/2016 Permit Issuer Notice Submittal of documents from administrative record

9 06/16/2016 Permittee Response of Salt River Project Agricultural Improvement and Power District to Petition for Review of Tribal Minor New Source Review Permit for the Navajo Generating Station

8 06/14/2016 Notice of Appearance by Salt River Project Argricultural Improvement and Power District

7 06/13/2016 Petitioner Notice NSR Oil Gas mandates digital images

6 06/13/2016 Permit Issuer Response Brief

4 05/31/2016 Permit Issuer Notice Certified Index to Administrative Record

5 05/31/2016 Petitioner Notice FerroAlloy NESHAP DCOT Req. Opacity May 2015

2 05/26/2016 Petitioner Notice NGS email and cert mail

1 05/23/2016 Navajo Generating Station

NSR 16-02

5

7

9

10 03/29/2017 Domestic Return Receipt - T. Gibbons

8 03/13/2017 Motion to Dismiss for Review

6 02/23/2017 Permit Issuer Joint Motion for Extension of Time

4 01/13/2017 Joint Motion for Extension of Time

3 01/09/2017 Petitioner Notice Certificate of Service

1 12/30/2016 Tesoro Logistics et al Petition for Review

2 12/30/2016 Email dated 12/30/2016 to S. McGrath, Regional Administrator, Region 8, a paper copy of the petition for review was sent via Federal Express

NSR 18-01

3

12

16

17

15 08/29/2018 EPA Region 8 Response in Opposition to Petitioner Motion for Leave to File Reply

14 08/21/2018 Notice of Intent to Oppose Petitioners Motion for Leave to File Reply

13 08/16/2018 Motion for Leave to File Reply

11 08/08/2018 Permittee Notice Consent to Service by Email

10 08/08/2018 Permittee Notice Withdrawal of Duplicate Filing

9 08/07/2018 Permit Issuer Consent to Email Service

8 08/06/2018 Permittee Response of Anadarko Uintah Midstream LLC Brief

7 08/06/2018 Permit Issuer Certified Index to the Administrative Record

6 08/06/2018 Permit Issuer EPA Region 8 Response to Petition for Review

Search this collection

Published Decisions: (Filings)

Local Navigation