Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Here’s how you know

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

HTTPS

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock (LockA locked padlock) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

  • Environmental Topics
  • Laws & Regulations
  • Report a Violation
  • About EPA

Title

  1. Home
  2. Environmental Appeals Board
  3. Filing: Dine Citizens Against Ruining the Environment, San Juan Citizen Alliance, Amigos Bravos, Center for Biological Diversity and Sierra Club Petition for Review (Arizona Public Service docket)

Filing - Dine Citizens Against Ruining the Environment, San Juan Citizen Alliance, Amigos Bravos, Center for Biological Diversity and Sierra Club Petition for Review


Additional Attachments

  • Attachment 1 - Final Permit (PDF) (1.01 MB)

  • Attachment 2 - cover letter (PDF) (0.35 MB)

  • Attachment 3 - Fact Sheet (PDF) (0.39 MB)

  • Attachment 4 - Response to Comments (PDF) (1.52 MB)

  • Attachment 5 - 7 percent share (PDF) (0.23 MB)

  • Attachment 6 - lease (PDF) (24.5 MB)

  • Attachment 7 - supplemental lease (PDF) (52.32 MB)

  • Attachment 8 - Exhibit 8 (PDF) (19.08 MB)

  • Attachment 9 - Exhibit 9 (PDF) (11.3 MB)

  • Attachment 10 - Exhibit 10 (PDF) (1.7 MB)

  • Attachment 11 - Exhibit 11 (PDF) (0.33 MB)

  • Attachment 12 - Exhibit 12 (PDF) (0.78 MB)

  • Attachment 13 - Exhibit 13 (PDF) (0.14 MB)

  • Attachment 14 - Exhibit 14 (PDF) (0.09 MB)

  • Attachment 15 - Exhibit 15 (PDF) (0.13 MB)

  • Attachment 16 - Exhibit 16 (PDF) (0.16 MB)

  • Attachment 17 - Exhibit 17 (PDF) (13.17 MB)

  • Attachment 18 - Exhibit 18 (PDF) (0.15 MB)

  • Attachment 19 - Exhibit 19 (PDF) (2.91 MB)

  • Attachment 20 - Exhibit 20 (PDF) (0.28 MB)

  • Attachment 21 - Exhibit 21 (PDF) (0.63 MB)

  • Attachment 22 - Exhibit 22 (PDF) (0.55 MB)

  • Attachment 23 - Exhibit 23 (PDF) (0.07 MB)

  • Attachment 24 - Exhibit 24 (PDF) (0.36 MB)

  • Attachment 25 - Exhibit 25 (PDF) (0.33 MB)

  • Attachment 26 - Exhibit 26 (PDF) (0.08 MB)

  • Attachment 27 - Exhibit 27 (PDF) (0.07 MB)

  • Attachment 28 - Exhibit 28 (PDF) (0.11 MB)

  • Attachment 29 - Exhibit 29 (PDF) (0.32 MB)

  • Attachment 30 - Exhibit 30 (PDF) (0.25 MB)

  • Attachment 31 - Exhibit 31 (PDF) (1.42 MB)

  • Attachment 32 - Exhibit 32 (PDF) (0.18 MB)

  • Attachment 33 - Exhibit 33 (PDF) (0.01 MB)

  • Attachment 34 - Exhibit 34 (PDF) (0.52 MB)

  • Attachment 35 - Exhibit 35 (PDF) (5.88 MB)

  • Attachment 36 - Exhibit 36 (PDF) (0.1 MB)

  • Attachment 37 - Exhibit 37 (PDF) (2.2 MB)

  • Attachment 38 - Exhibit 38 (PDF) (0.49 MB)

  • Attachment 39 - Exhibit 39 (PDF) (0.08 MB)

  • Attachment 40 - Exhibit 40 (PDF) (0.09 MB)

  • Attachment 41 - Exhibit 41 (PDF) (7.61 MB)

  • Attachment 42 - Exhibit 42 (PDF) (4.43 MB)

  • Attachment 43 - Exhibit 43 (PDF) (0.29 MB)

  • Attachment 44 - Exhibit 44 (PDF) (0.36 MB)

  • Attachment 45 - Exhibit 45 (PDF) (0.91 MB)

  • Attachment 46 - Exhibit 46 (PDF) (7.07 MB)

  • Attachment 47 - Exhibit 47 (PDF) (0.57 MB)

  • Attachment 48 - Exhibit 48 (PDF) (2.54 MB)

  • Attachment 49 - Exhibit 49 (PDF) (0.47 MB)

  • Attachment 50 - Exhibit 50 (PDF) (1.74 MB)

  • Attachment 51 - Exhibit 51 (PDF) (2.82 MB)

  • Attachment 52 - Exhibit 52 (PDF) (5.42 MB)

  • Attachment 53 - Exhibit 53 (PDF) (0.15 MB)

  • Attachment 54 - Exhibit 54 (PDF) (23.81 MB)

  • Attachment 55 - Exhibit 55 (PDF) (1.09 MB)

  • Attachment 56 - Exhibit 56 (PDF) (4.64 MB)

  • Attachment 57 - Exhibit 57 (PDF) (0.2 MB)

  • Attachment 58 - Exhibit 58 (PDF) (0.16 MB)

  • Attachment 59 - Exhibit 59 (PDF) (10.06 MB)

  • Attachment 60 - Exhibit 60 (PDF) (0.1 MB)

  • Attachment 61 - Exhibit 61 (PDF) (0.98 MB)

  • Attachment 62 - Exhibit 62 (PDF) (0.53 MB)

  • Attachment 63 - Exhibit 63 (PDF) (0.46 MB)

  • Attachment 64 - Exhibit 64 (PDF) (0.95 MB)

  • Attachment 65 - Exhibit 65 (PDF) (0.82 MB)

  • Attachment 66 - Exhibit 66 (PDF) (0.92 MB)

  • Attachment 67 - Exhibit 67 (PDF) (0.73 MB)

  • Attachment 68 - Exhibit 68 (PDF) (0.21 MB)

  • Attachment 69 - Exhibit 69 (PDF) (1.09 MB)

  • Attachment 70 - Exhibit 70 (PDF) (0.46 MB)

  • Attachment 71 - Exhibit 71 (PDF) (0.38 MB)

  • Attachment 72 - Exhibit 72 (PDF) (0.53 MB)

  • Attachment 73 - Exhibit 73 (PDF) (24.74 MB)

Link to Filing (PDF )
Appeal Number(s)NPDES 19-06
Filing Number1
Filing Date11/01/2019
Case NameArizona Public Service

Environmental Appeals Board

  • EAB Home Page
  • EAB Dockets & Decisions
  • Federal Court Review
  • Rules & Standing Orders Governing Appeals
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution
  • Electronic Filing
  • Upcoming Oral Arguments
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • General Information
Contact Us
Contact Us to ask a question, provide feedback, or report a problem.Last updated on April 20, 2026
United States Environmental Protection Agency

Discover.

  • Accessibility Statement
  • Budget & Performance
  • Contracting
  • EPA www Web Snapshots
  • Grants
  • No FEAR Act Data
  • Privacy
  • Privacy and Security Notice

Connect.

  • Data
  • Inspector General
  • Jobs
  • Newsroom
  • Open Government
  • Regulations.gov
  • Subscribe
  • USA.gov
  • White House

Ask.

  • Contact EPA
  • EPA Disclaimers
  • Hotlines
  • FOIA Requests
  • Frequent Questions

Follow.

Last updated on April 20, 2026