Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Here’s how you know

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

HTTPS

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock (LockA locked padlock) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

  • Environmental Topics
  • Laws & Regulations
  • Report a Violation
  • About EPA

Title

  1. Home
  2. Environmental Appeals Board
  3. Energy Answers Arecibo, LLC docket

Energy Answers Arecibo, LLC


StatusClosed
File Date07/12/2013
Appeal Number(s)PSD 13-05; PSD 13-06; PSD 13-07; PSD 13-08; PSD 13-09
Docket NumberN/A
Statute(s)Clean Air Act
TypePERMIT
Program(s)New Source Review
Index of Filings
  • #1 - 07/03/2013 - Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
  • #2 - 07/02/2013 - The Coalition of Organizations Against Incinerators Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
  • #3 - 07/08/2013 - Opposition to Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
  • #4 - 07/09/2013 - EPA Region 2's Response to Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
  • #4.1 - 07/09/2013 - Exhibits for EPA Region 2's Response to Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
  • #5 - 07/10/2013 - Energy Answers Arecibo. LLC's Reply to EPA Region 2's Response to Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
  • #6 - 07/11/2013 - Order Granting in Part Extension of Tme to File Petition for Review
  • #7 - 07/12/2013 - Quinones Dominguez, Petition for Review (PSD 13-06)
  • #8 - 07/16/2013 - LLenza Petition for Review (PSD 13-07)
  • #9 - 07/16/2013 - Galan, Petition for Review (PSD 13-08)
  • #10 - 07/22/2013 - The Coalition of Organizations Against Incinerators Petition for Review (PSD 13-05)
  • #10-06 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 4 Angel Written Comment (1)
  • #10.01 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Conty Written Comment (1)
  • #10.02 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Conty Written Comment (2)
  • #10.03 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Conty Written Comment (3)
  • #10.04 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 1 Angel Written Comment (1)
  • #10.04 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 1 Angel Written Comment (1)
  • #10.05 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 3 Angel Written Comment (1)
  • #10.06 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 4 Angel Written Comment (1)
  • #10.07 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 5 Angel Written Comment (1)
  • #10.08 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 2 Angel Written Comment (1)
  • #10.09 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 6 Angel Written Comment (2)
  • #10.09 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 6 Angel Written Comment (2)
  • #10.10 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Segment 7 Moreno Written Comments
  • #10.11 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Gonzalez Written Comments
  • #10.12 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Osvaldo Written Comment (slides) 1
  • #10.13 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Osvaldo Written Comment (slides) 2
  • #10.14 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Osvaldo Written Comment (slides) 3
  • #10.15 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Osvaldo Written Comment (slides) 4
  • #10.16 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Osvaldo Written Comment (slides) 5
  • #10.17 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Osvaldo Written Comment (slides) 6
  • #10.18 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Osvaldo Written Comment (slides) 7
  • #10.19 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Orlando Negron Sierra Club Written Comment
  • #10.20 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Osvaldo Written Comment (slides) 8
  • #10.21 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Rodriguez Written Comment
  • #10.22 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Sanchez Written Comment
  • #10.23 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1 Serrano Written Comment
  • #10.24 - 07/22/2013 - Response to Petition Exhibit 1(b) Hearing Transcript (2,3,4,5)
  • #10.25 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 2 EPA Responses to Public
  • #10.26 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 1(b) Hearing Transcript (6)
  • #10.27 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 3 Environmental Justice Evaluation (excerpts)
  • #10.28 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 4 PSD Air Permit Application (excerpts)
  • #10.29 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 5 Nonattainment Status for Puerto Rico
  • #10.30 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 6 EPA Letter and TSD on Nonattainment
  • #10.31 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 6 EPA Letter and TSD on Nonattainment
  • #10.32 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 7 Battery Recycling Draft Title V Permit
  • #10.33 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Data (List of Arecino Facilities
  • #10.34 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 8 TRI Form R (2011) (Battery Recycling Company)
  • #10.35 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (1-Battery Recycling Facility)
  • #10.36 - 07/22/2013 - Petiton for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (2 Continental Flavors)
  • #10.37 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (3-Cutter Hammer)
  • #10.38 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (5 Hudson)
  • #10.39 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (4 GE Industrial)
  • #10.39 - 07/24/2013 -
  • #10.40 - 07/22/2013 - Petiton for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (6 Kayser-Roth)
  • #10.41 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (7-Maycom)
  • #10.42 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (8-MSD International)
  • #10.42 - 07/25/2013 -
  • #10.43 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (9-Pfizer)
  • #10.44 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (10-Prasa)
  • #10.45 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (11-PREPA)
  • #10.46 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 9 TRI Historical Data (TRI Historical Data (12-Thermo King)
  • #10.47 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 10 Arecibo Nonattainment Area Map and Description
  • #10.48 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 11 EPA Response Letter to Arcadis, (October 11, 2011)
  • #10.49 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 12 rcadis Letter to EPA (October 26, 2011)
  • #10.50 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Arcadis Letter to EPA (October 26, 2011)
  • #10.51 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 12 Arcadis Letter to EPA (October 26, 2011
  • #10.52 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 13(1) EPA Press Release 1 (June 9, 2011)
  • #10.53 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 13(3) EPA Press Release 3 (August 10, 2011)
  • #10.54 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 13(2) EPA Press Release 2 (June 15, 2011)
  • #10.55 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review EExhibit 14 Take Home Lead Exposure Stury (MMWR)
  • #10.56 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 13(4) EPA Press Release (4) (February 23, 2012)
  • #10.57 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 15 CDC Publication on Asthma in Puerto Rico
  • #10.58 - 07/22/2013 - Petition for Review Exhibit 16 Puerto Rico DOH Fact Sheet on Asthma
  • #11 - 07/23/2013 - Flores Flores & Centeno Rodriguez Petition for Review
  • #12 - 07/26/2013 - Energy Answers Arecibo, LLC's Motion for an Extension of Time and Consolidated Response to PSD Appeal Nos. 13-05, 13-06, 13-07 and 13-08
  • #13 - 07/23/2013 - Petition of Appeal (PSD 13-07) in hard copy and the internet print screens regarding the use of the new CDX webpage
  • #14 - 07/30/2013 - Energy Answers Arecibo, LLC's Amended Motion for an Extension of Time and Consolidated Response to PSD Appeal Nos. 13-05, 13-06, 13-07, 13-08 and 13-09
  • #15 - 07/31/2013 - Motion to Dismiss Flores and Centeno Petition for Review
  • #16 - 08/01/2013 - Order Granting Motion to File Consolidated Response But Denying In Part Motion for Extension
  • #17 - 07/26/2013 - Certified Index to the Adminstrative Record
  • #18 - 08/02/2013 - Order on Timeliness of Petitions Filed and Denying Region's Motion to Dismiss
  • #19 - 08/12/2013 - Permittee Response Brief (9 additional attachments)
  • #20 - 08/12/2013 - Permit Issuer Response Brief (1 additional attachments)
  • #21 - 08/12/2013 - Permit Issuer Excerpts of Record (21 additional attachments)
  • #22 - 08/26/2013 - Coalition's Opposed 1st Motion For Leave to File a Reply (1 additional attachments)
  • #23 - 09/10/2013 - Opposition to Motion of the Coalition of Organizations Against Incineratiors for Leave to Submit a Reply Brief
  • #24 - 09/20/2013 - Petitioner Reply Brief
  • #25 - 11/14/2013 - Region 2 Motion for Limited Voluntary Remand (5 additional attachments)
  • #26 - 11/29/2013 - Response to EPA Region 2 Motion for Limited Voluntary Remand (1 additional attachments)
  • #27 - 12/02/2013 - Permittee Brief in Support of EPA Region 2 Motion for a Limited Voluntary Remand
  • #28 - 12/03/2013 - Response to EPA Region 2 Motion for Limited Voluntary Remand
  • #29 - 12/03/2013 - Informative Motion and to Request Documents
  • #30 - 12/06/2013 - Permit Issuer Notice Certificate of Service (supplemental) for Administrative Record Index
  • #31 - 12/06/2013 - EPA Region 2's Reply to the Petitioners' Responses to Region 2's Motion for Limited Voluntary Remand and Response to Motion to Request Documents (1 additional attachments)
  • #32 - 03/25/2014 - Order Remanding in Part and Denying Review in Part
  • #33 - 04/04/2014 - Motion Requesting Leave to Intervene (1 additional attachments)
  • #34 - 04/04/2014 - Motion Requesting Extension of Time to File for Reconsideration (1 additional attachments)
  • #35 - 04/11/2014 - Order Denying Motion to Intervene
  • #36 - 04/11/2014 - Order Denying Motion Requesting Extension of Time to File for Reconsideration
  • #37 - 04/07/2014 - Order Remanding in Part and Denying review in Part addressed to W. Natalio Flores Flores "Return to Sender -- Vacant" (HARD COPY ONLY)
  • #38 - 04/08/2014 - Order Remanding in Part and Denying review in Part addressed to E. Llenza "Returned For Better Address" (HARD COPY ONLY)
  • #39 - 04/08/2014 - Notice of Errata
  • #40 - 04/24/2014 - Received via email -- Motion Requesting Rehearing
  • #41 - 04/24/2014 - Received via email -- Motion of Recusal of Hon Judge K. A. Stein
  • #42 - 04/29/2014 - Order Denying Motions for Recusal and Rehearing
  • #43 - 04/23/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt -- C. Galan et al
  • #44 - 05/12/2014 - Received via email-- Motion for Leave to File Via Email
  • #45 - 05/12/2014 - Received via email -- Motion for Recusal of Panel and Rehearing by the EPA Administrator
  • #46 - 05/30/2014 - Order Denying Motion for Recusal of Panel and Denying Referral to Administrator for Rehearing
  • #47 - 06/06/2014 - Order Remanding in Part and Denying Review in Part, dated March 25, 2014 -- mailed to E. Llenza,via Certified Mail was Returned to Sender "Unclaimed" (HARD COPY ONLY)
  • #48 - 06/02/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt -- D. Frost et al
  • #49 - 06/13/2014 - Received via email -- Motion to Quash
  • #50 - 06/13/2014 - Consolidated Motion for Leave to File Via Email
  • #51 - 06/17/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - Order Denying Motion for Recusal of Panel and Denying Referral to Administrative for Rehearing
  • #52 - 06/24/2014 - Order Denying Motion to Quash
  • #53 - 06/11/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt
  • #54 - 06/26/2014 - Order Denying Motion for Recusal of Panel and Denying Referral to Administrator for Rehearing mailed to C. Galan was returned "Unclaimed" on 6/26/2014 (HARD COPY ONLY)
  • #55 - 07/01/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt F. Arraiza Navas
  • #56 - 07/02/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt C. D. Ahlers
  • #57 - 07/07/2014 - Motion Seeking Clarification of Order
  • #57.01 - 07/07/2014 - Motion For Leave to File VIA Email
  • #57.02 - 07/07/2014 - Screenshot; attempted to file "Motion Seeking Clarification of Order" via the efiling portal
  • #58 - 07/07/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt -- D. Frost
  • #59 - 07/11/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - Flores Flores
  • #60 - 07/11/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - Ramos-Hernandez
  • #61 - 07/15/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - Cristina Galan
  • #62 - 07/21/2014 - Order Denying Motion to Quash mailed to A. C. Rodriguez; "Return to Sender Unclaimed, Unable to Forward" (HARD COPY ONLY)
  • #63 - 07/22/2014 - Order
  • #65 - 07/29/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt -- D. J. Frost and H. C. Eisenberg
  • #66 - 08/01/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - C. Galan
  • #67 - 08/04/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - C. Ahlers
  • #68 - 08/04/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - M. Dominquez
  • #69 - 08/04/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - F. Navas
  • #70 - 08/11/2014 - Order Denying Motion to Quash -- to Eliza Llenza, Return to Sender Unclaimed Unable to Forward (HARD COPY ONLY)
  • #71 - 08/11/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - W. Flores Flores
  • #72 - 08/15/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - E. Lenza
  • #73 - 08/15/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt - A. Rodriquez
  • #74 - 09/05/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt -- L. Hernandez
  • #75 - 09/22/2014 - Domestic Return Receipt -- L. Ramos-Hernandez

Print Index

Environmental Appeals Board

  • EAB Home Page
  • EAB Dockets & Decisions
  • Federal Court Review
  • Rules & Standing Orders Governing Appeals
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution
  • Electronic Filing
  • Upcoming Oral Arguments
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • General Information
Contact Us
Contact Us to ask a question, provide feedback, or report a problem.Last updated on May 20, 2026
United States Environmental Protection Agency

Discover.

  • Accessibility Statement
  • Budget & Performance
  • Contracting
  • EPA www Web Snapshots
  • Grants
  • No FEAR Act Data
  • Privacy
  • Privacy and Security Notice

Connect.

  • Data
  • Inspector General
  • Jobs
  • Newsroom
  • Open Government
  • Regulations.gov
  • Subscribe
  • USA.gov
  • White House

Ask.

  • Contact EPA
  • EPA Disclaimers
  • Hotlines
  • FOIA Requests
  • Frequent Questions

Follow.

Last updated on May 20, 2026