Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Here’s how you know

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

HTTPS

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock (LockA locked padlock) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

  • Environmental Topics
  • Laws & Regulations
  • Report a Violation
  • About EPA

Title

  1. Home
  2. Environmental Appeals Board
  3. Case sort order: CAA Decisions

Published Decisions: CAA Decisions


(117 records in this collection) Click for full-text searchSearch this collection | Search entire database

Decision DateCase NameCitationAppeal No.TypeProgram
09/10/2024Deseret Generation and Transmission Co-operative Bonanza Power Plant19 E.A.D. 67CAA 24-01Permit
01/10/2022AJAX Materials Corporation 18 E.A.D. 572CAA 21-04PermitNew Source Review
09/02/2020MPLX18 E.A.D. 228CAA 20-01PermitTitle V
07/21/2020Veolia ES Technical Solutions LLC18 E.A.D. 194CAA 19-01PermitTitle V
03/05/2020Taotao USA, Inc. Taotao Group Co.18 E.A.D. 40CAA 18-01 and .....Penalty
12/03/2018Tucson Electric Power 17 E.A.D. 675PSD 18-02PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
11/15/2018Anadarko Uintah Midstream LLC17 E.A.D. 656NSR 18-01PermitNew Source Review
10/23/2018Palmdale Energy, LLC17 E.A.D. 620PSD 18-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
06/20/2017Delta Energy Center17 E.A.D. 371PSD 17-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
12/22/2016Peace Industry Group (USA), Inc. Zhejiang Peace Industry and Trade Co., Ltd, Cho...17 E.A.D. 348CAA 16-01Penalty
09/01/2016Arizona Public Service Company Ocotillo Power Plant17 E.A.D. 323PSD 16-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
08/30/2016Navajo Generating Station17 E.A.D. 312NSR 16-01PermitNew Source Review
09/02/2014Footprint Power Salem Harbor Development, LP16 E.A.D. 546PSD 14-02PermitNew Source Review
05/14/2014ExxonMobil Chemical Company Baytown Olefins Plant16 E.A.D. 383PSD 13-11PermitNew Source Review
04/10/2014Sierra Pacific Industries16 E.A.D. 375PSD 14-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
03/25/2014Energy Answers Arecibo, LLC 16 E.A.D. 294PSD 13-05 and .....PermitNew Source Review
03/14/2014La Paloma Energy Center, LLC16 E.A.D. 267PSD 13-10PermitNew Source Review
12/06/2013Berry Petroleum Company16 E.A.D. 263CAA 13-03Penalty
08/02/2013Pio Pico Energy Center, LLC16 E.A.D. 56PSD 12-04 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
07/18/2013Sierra Pacific Industries16 E.A.D. 1PSD 13-01 and .....PermitNew Source Review,Prevention of Significant Deterioration
01/25/2013Peabody Western Coal Company15 E.A.D. 757CAA 12-01PermitTitle V
09/17/2012City of Palmdale 15 E.A.D. 700PSD 11-07PermitNew Source Review
03/30/2012Shell Offshore, Inc.15 E.A.D. 536OCS 11-05 and .....PermitOuter Continental Shelf Air Regulations
03/13/2012Peabody Western Coal Co.15 E.A.D. 524CAA 11-01PermitTitle V
01/12/2012Shell Gulf of Mexico, Inc. 15 E.A.D. 470OCS 11-02 and .....PermitOuter Continental Shelf Air Regulations
08/18/2011Avenal Power Center, LLC15 E.A.D. 384PSD 11-02 and .....PermitNew Source Review
08/09/2011Mississippi Lime Company15 E.A.D. 349PSD 11-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
05/20/2011Cape Wind Associates, LLC15 E.A.D. 327OCS 11-01PermitOuter Continental Shelf Air Regulations
03/14/2011Shell Gulf of Mexico Inc. and Shell Offshore Inc.15 E.A.D. 193OCS 10-01 and .....PermitOuter Continental Shelf Air Regulations
03/02/2011Vulcan Construction Materials, LP15 E.A.D. 163PSD 10-11PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
12/30/2010Shell Gulf of Mexico Inc. and Shell Offshore Inc.15 E.A.D. 103OCS 10-01 and .....PermitOuter Continental Shelf Air Regulations
11/18/2010Russell City Energy Center, LLC15 E.A.D. 1PSD 10-01 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
08/13/2010Power Holdings of Illinois, LLC 14 E.A.D. 723PSD 09-04PermitNew Source Review
08/13/2010Peabody Western Coal Company14 E.A.D. 712CAA 10-01PermitTitle V
09/24/2009Desert Rock Energy Company, LLC14 E.A.D. 484PSD 08-03 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
09/22/2009Seminole Electric Cooperative, Inc.14 E.A.D. 468PSD 08-09PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
02/18/2009Northern Michigan University14 E.A.D. 283PSD 08-02PermitNew Source Review
11/13/2008Deseret Power Electric Cooperative (Bonanza)14 E.A.D. 212PSD 07-03PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
07/29/2008Russell City Energy Center14 E.A.D. 159PSD 08-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
06/02/2008Conocophillips Company13 E.A.D. 768PSD 07-02PermitNew Source Review
01/28/2008Christian County Generation, LLC13 E.A.D. 449PSD 07-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
09/14/2007Shell Offshore, Inc. (Kulluk Drilling Unit and Frontier Discoverer Drilling Unit13 E.A.D. 357OCS 07-01 and .....PermitOuter Continental Shelf Air Regulations
07/11/2007City of Wilkes-Barre, A.R. Popple, Inc., Wyoming S. & P., Inc.13 E.A.D. 332CAA 06-03Penalty
09/27/2006Indeck-Elwood LLC13 E. A D. 126PSD 03-04PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
08/24/2006Prairie State Generating Co.13 E.A.D. 1PSD 05-05PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
07/11/2006Four Strong Builders, Inc.12 E.A.D. 762CAA 05-02Penalty
12/21/2005Newmont Nevada Energy Investment, L.L.C., TS Power Plant12 E.A.D. 429PSD 05-04PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
09/30/2005Chippewa Hazardous Waste Remediation & Energy, Inc. d/b/a Chippewa Hazardous Was...12 E.A.D. 346CAA 04-02Penalty
09/30/2005JHNY, Inc. a/k/a Quin-T Technical Papers and Boards12 E.A.D. 372CAA 04-09Penalty
06/21/2005BP West Coast Products, LLC, Cherry Point Co-generation Facility12 E.A.D. 209PSD 05-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
03/25/2005Prairie State Generation Station12 E.A.D. 176PSD 05-02PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
03/22/2005Cardinal FG Company12 E.A.D. 153PSD 04-04PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
02/18/2005Peabody Western Coal Company12 E.A.D. 22CAA 04-01PermitNew Source Review,Title V
02/01/2005Amerada Hess Corporation, Port Reading Refinery Facility12 E.A.D. 1PSD 04-03PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
08/03/2004Rochester Public Utilities11 E.A.D. 593 PSD 03-03PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
07/23/2004Julie's Limousine & Coachworks, Inc.11 E.A.D. 498CAA 03-06Penalty
02/18/2004Morton L. Friedman and Schmitt Construction Company11 E.A.D. 302CAA 02-07Penalty
01/29/2004Consumers Scrap Recycling, Inc.11 E.A.D. 269CAA 02-06 and .....PenaltySection 3008
10/20/2003B & L Plating, Inc.11 E.A.D. 183CAA 02-08Penalty
06/05/2003CDT Landfill Corporation11 E.A.D. 88CAA 02-02Penalty
06/05/2003U.S. Army, Fort Wainwright Central Heating & Power Plant11 E.A.D. 126CAA 02-04Penalty
04/29/2003Kendall New Century Development11 E.A.D.40PSD 03-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
01/07/2003Sierra Pacific Industries11 E.A.D. 1PSD 02-13PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
07/31/2002Hillman Power Company, LLC10 E.A.D. 673PSD 02-04 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
04/01/2002Lyon County Landfill10 E.A.D. 416CAA 00-5Penalty
03/06/2002General Motors Corporation10 E.A.D. 360PSD 01-30PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
11/27/2001Hawaii Electric Light Company, Inc.10 E.A.D. 219PSD 01-24 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
06/26/2001LVI Environmental Services, Inc10 E.A.D. 99CAA 00-8Penalty
05/30/2001Three Mountain Power, LLC10 E.A.D. 39PSD 01-05PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
04/23/2001Steel Dynamics, Inc9 E.A.D. 740PSD 01-03PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
03/28/2001Tondu Energy Company9 E.A.D. 710PSD 00-5 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
03/27/2001Zion Energy, LLC9 E.A.D. 701PSD 01-01PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
03/13/2001DPL Energy, Montpelier Electric Generating Station9 E.A.D. 695PSD 01-02PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
02/28/2001Carlton, Inc., North Shore Power Plant9 E.A.D. 690PSD 00-9PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
02/15/2001Allegheny Power Service Corp.9 E.A.D. 636CAA 99-4Penalty
09/15/2000Tennessee Valley Authority9 E.A.D. 357CAA 00-6Compliance Order
06/22/2000Steel Dynamics, Inc.9 E.A.D. 165PSD 99-4 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
03/14/2000Knauf Fiber Glass, GmbH9 E.A.D. 1PSD 99-8 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
12/02/1999Sutter Power Plant8 E.A.D. 680PSD 99-6 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
10/18/1999Milford Power Plant8 E.A.D. 670PSD 99-2PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
08/26/1999Lyon County Landfill8 E.A.D. 559CAA 98-6Penalty
08/25/1999Rockgen Energy Center8 E.A.D. 536PSD 99-1PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
07/07/1999Schoolcraft Construction, Inc.8 E.A.D. 476CAA 98-3Penalty
06/22/1999EK Associates, L.P. d/b/a EKCO/GLACO and EK Management Corp.8 E.A.D. 458CAA 98-4Penalty
05/27/1999AES Puerto Rico, L.P.8 E.A.D. 324PSD 98-29 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
05/25/1999Jiffy Builders, Inc.8 E.A.D. 315CAA 98-2Penalty
03/26/1999Encogen Cogeneration Facility8 E.A.D. 244PSD 98-22 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
03/10/1999West Suburban Recycling and Energy Center, L.P.8 E.A.D. 192PSD 97-12PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
02/04/1999Knauf Fiber Glass, GmbH8 E.A.D. 121PSD 98-3 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
11/25/1998Hawaii Electric Light Company, Inc.8 E.A.D. 66PSD 97-15 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
09/10/1998Maui Electric Company8 E.A.D. 1PSD 98-2PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
07/30/1998Commercial Cartage Company7 E.A.D. 784CAA 97-9Penalty
03/13/1998Ocean State Asbestos Removal, Inc.7 E.A.D. 522CAA 97-5Penalty
02/09/1998Schoolcraft Construction, Inc.7 E.A.D. 501CAA 97-1Penalty
07/17/1997Woodkiln, Inc.7 E.A.D. 254CAA 96-2PermitWood Heater Certificate
04/28/1997Kawaihae Cogeneration Project7 E.A.D. 107PSD 96-9 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
04/08/1997Ecoeléctrica, L.P.7 E.A.D. 56PSD 96-8 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
02/19/1997Commonwealth Chesapeake Corp.6 E.A.D. 764PSD 96-2 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
12/11/1996West Suburban Recycling and Energy Center, L.P.6 E.A.D. 692PSD 95-1PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
06/19/1996Campo Landfill Project6 E.A.D. 505NSR 95-1PermitNew Source Review
12/11/1995Puerto Rico Electric Power Authority (Cambalache Combustion Turbine Project)6 E.A.D. 253PSD 95-2PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
07/25/1995Umetco Minerals Corporation6 E.A.D. 127CAA 94-6Penalty
05/15/1995Indianapolis Power & Light Company, Petersburg Plant6 E.A.D. 23CAA 95-1PermitAcid Rain
12/21/1994Norma J. & Frank J. Echevarria d/b/a Echeco Environmental Services5 E.A.D. 626CAA 94-1Penalty
11/01/1994Masonite Corporation5 E.A.D. 551PSD 94-1PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
04/18/1994Essex County (N.J.) Resource Recovery Facility5 E.A.D. 218PSD 93-10PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
03/16/1994Inter-Power of New York, Inc.5 E.A.D. 130PSD 92-8 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
02/22/1994Commercial Cartage Company, Inc.5 E.A.D. 112CAA 93-2Penalty
02/15/1994Burlington Northern Railroad Company5 E.A.D. 106CAA 93-3Penalty
01/27/1994SEI Birchwood, Inc.5 E.A.D. 25PSD 93-11 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
01/05/1994Crown/Vista Energy Project (CVEP) West Deptford, New Jersey5 E.A.D. 1PSD 93-15 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
10/22/1993Genesee Power Station Limited Partnership4 E.A.D. 832PSD 93-1 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
02/02/1993House Analysis Associates & Fred Powell4 E.A.D. 501CAA 93-1Penalty
12/01/1992Ogden Martin Systems of Onondaga, Inc. and Onondaga County Resource Recovery Fac...4 A.E.D. 405PSD 92-7PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
10/05/1992Hadson Power 14--Buena Vista4 E.A.D. 258PSD 92-3 and .....PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
07/20/1992Hawaiian Commercial & Sugar Company4 E.A.D. 95PSD 92-1PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration
04/29/1992Multitrade Limited Partnership4 E.A.D. 24PSD 92-2PermitPrevention of Significant Deterioration

Environmental Appeals Board

  • EAB Home Page
  • EAB Dockets & Decisions
  • Federal Court Review
  • Rules & Standing Orders Governing Appeals
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution
  • Electronic Filing
  • Upcoming Oral Arguments
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • General Information
Contact Us
Contact Us to ask a question, provide feedback, or report a problem.Last updated on June 15, 2026
United States Environmental Protection Agency

Discover.

  • Accessibility Statement
  • Budget & Performance
  • Contracting
  • EPA www Web Snapshots
  • Grants
  • No FEAR Act Data
  • Privacy
  • Privacy and Security Notice

Connect.

  • Data
  • Inspector General
  • Jobs
  • Newsroom
  • Open Government
  • Regulations.gov
  • Subscribe
  • USA.gov
  • White House

Ask.

  • Contact EPA
  • EPA Disclaimers
  • Hotlines
  • FOIA Requests
  • Frequent Questions

Follow.

Last updated on June 15, 2026