US EPA Environmental Appeals Board



Case Index for UIC 19-02 - Muskegon Development Company

01/21/2026 02:28:52 AM


Filing #: 1 - 10/25/2019 - Petition for Review Reply Brief is in Response to the Remanded Response to Petitions filed against Muskegon Development Class II Injection Appeal No. 18-05

Filing #: 2 - 10/31/2019 - Permit Issuer Notice of Appearance

Filing #: 3 - 11/04/2019 - Order to Show Cause Why Petition Should Not Be Dismissed For Lack of Jurisdiction, And Regarding Service Via Electronic Mail

Filing #: 4 - 11/13/2019 - Petitioners's Response to Order to Show Cause

   #4.01 - Signed Revised RTC on Draft Class II Permit in Clare County MI Issued to Muskegon Develop. Co. #MI-035-2R-0034

   #4.02 - Revised Petition for Review and Response to Revised response to comment MI-035-2R-0034

   #4.03 - PSE Cement Failure Causes and Rate Analaysis Jan 2013 Ingraffea

   #4.04 - Muskegon Order to Show Cause Why Petition Should Not Be Dismissed

Filing #: 5 - 11/20/2019 - Permit Issuer Reply Brief

Filing #: 6 - 11/25/2019 - Permit Issuer Response Brief

   #6.01 - Revised Response to Comments - UIC App No. 19-02

   #6.02 - Signed EPA R5 Permit Letter - UIC App No. 19-02

   #6.03 - Administrative Record - EPA R5 _ UIC App No. 19-02

   #6.04 - Administrative Record - EPA R5 - UIC App No. 19-02

   #6.05 - Administrative Record - EPA R5 - UIC App No. 19-02

Filing #: 7 - 11/26/2019 - Permit Issuer Paper Copy of Document with Attachment Exceeding 50 pp and Certification

Filing #: 8 - 12/02/2019 - Petitioner Opposed 1st Motion For Leave to File

   #8.01 - EPA reply to Petition Response to Order to show cause

   #8.02 - Draft Permit

   #8.03 - Order to Show Cause Why Petition Should not be dismissed

   #8.04 - Response Brief for Oder to Show Cause MI-035-2R-0034

   #8.05 - Revised Petition for Review and Response to Revised response to comment MI-035-2R-0034

   #8.06 - Signed Revised RTC on Draft Class II Permit in Clare County MI Issued to Muskegon Develop. Co. #MI-035-2R-0034

Filing #: 9 - 12/04/2019 - Order Granting Motion for Leave to File Surreply and Regarding Further Briefing

Filing #: 10 - 12/10/2019 - Petitioner Reply Brief

   #10.01 - record of well completion

   #10.02 - report of loss or spill

   #10.03 - epa response brief

   #10.04 - Ingraffea, Anthony, 2013, Fluid Migration Mechanisms Due to Faulty Well Design and/or Construction: An Overview of Recent Experiences in the Pennsylvania Marcellus Play, Physicians, Scientists, and Engineers for Healthy Energy

   #10.05 - response brief for order to show cause

   #10.06 - Revised Petition for Review and Response to Revised response to comment MI-035-2R-0034

   #10.07 - Signed Revised RTC on Draft Class II Permit in Clare County MI Issued to Muskegon Develop. Co. #MI-035-2R-0034

Filing #: 11 - 02/11/2020 - Order Directing Clarification

Filing #: 12 - 02/21/2020 - Permit Issuer EPA Region 5 Response to Order Directing Clarification

   #12.01 - 10/2/2019 email to commenters

   #12.02 - ResponsetoComments Transmittal (Tanaka Letter) 9/26/2019

   #12.03 - Transmittal Letter Final Permit 9/26/2019 (to MDC)

   #12.04 - Revised RtC 9/26/2019

   #12.05 - redacted Mail list from mailed and emailed commenters

Filing #: 13 - 02/21/2020 - Permit Issuer Permit Issuer EPA Region 5 Response to Order Directing Clarification

   #13.01 - 10/2/2019 email to commenters

   #13.02 - ResponsetoComments Transmittal (Tanaka Letter) 9/26/2019

   #13.03 - Transmittal Letter Final Permit 9/26/2019 (to MDC)

   #13.04 - Revised RtC 9/26/2019

   #13.05 - redacted Mail list from mailed and emailed commenters

   #13.06 - Certificate of Service 10/2/2019

   #13.07 - Class II underground injection final permit 9/26/2019 to MDC

   #13.08 - EPA Region 5 UIC Standard Operating Procedure for Public Participation

   #13.09 - 40 CFR Part 124.15

   #13.10 - 40 CFR Part 124.15

   #13.11 - Results of February 13 and 18, 2020 internet searches of publicly available Region 5 Hearing documents for Permit MI-035-2R-0034

Filing #: 14 - 03/26/2020 - Order Denying Review