City and County of Honolulu's Sand Island Wastewater Treatment Plant; City and County of Honolulu's Honouliuli Wastewater Treatment Plant

Status	Closed
File Date	01/23/2009
Appeal Number(s)	NPDES 09-01
Docket Number	HI0020117; HI0020877
Statute(s)	Clean Water Act
Type	PERMIT
Program(s)	NPDES

Index of Filings

#1 - 01/23/2009 - Motion for Extension of Time to File Petitions for Review

#2 - 01/23/2009 - City and County of Honolulu's Sand Island Wastewater Treatment Plant and Permit No. HI0020117; City and County of Honolulu's Honouliuli Wastewater Treatment Plant Permit No. HI0020877 (HARD COPY ONLY)

#3 - 01/30/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA Region 9's Response to Motion for Extension of Time to File Petitions for Review

#4 - 01/30/2009 - EPA Region IX's Response to Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (HARD COPY ONLY)

#5 - 02/02/2009 - Order Granting Alternative Motion for Extension of Time to File Petitions for Review

#6 - 02/02/2009 - Facsimile Cover Sheet -- David Salmons, Esq. et al -- Order Granting Alternative Motion for Extension of Time to File Petitions for Review

#7 - 02/09/2009 - Motion to Consolidate Petitions for Review/Consolidated Petitions for Review in Appeal NPDES No. 09-01

#8 - 02/27/2009 - Letter from Patrick K. Sullivan, Ph.D., commented on the tentative Denial of the 301(h) Waiver Application for Appeal Number NPDES 09-01

#9 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review

#9.1 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit A 9.1

#9.2 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit A Cont'd 9.2

#9.3 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit A Cont'd 9.3

#9.4 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit A Cont'd 9.4

#9.5 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit A Cont'd 9.5

#9.6 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit B 9.6

#9.7 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit C 9.7

#9.8 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit C Cont'd 9.8

#9.9 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit C Cont'd 9.9

#10 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit C Cont'd 10

#10.1 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit D 10.1

#10.2 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit D Cont'd 10.2

#10.3 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit D Cont'd 10.3

#10.4 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit D Cont'd 10.4

#10.5 - 03/11/2009 - Supplemental Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review - Exhibit D Cont'd 10.5

#11 - 03/31/2009 - Order Granting Motion to Consolidate and Directing Response to Petition for Review

#12 - 03/31/2009 - Facsimile Cover Sheet -- David Salmons et al - Order Granting Motion to Consolidate and Directing Response to Petition for Review

#13 - 04/23/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Joint Motion for Extension and Stay of Consideration

#14 - 04/23/2009 - Original -- Joint Motion for Extension and Stay of Consideration (HARD COPY ONLY)

#15 - 04/27/2009 - Order Granting Motion for Extension to File Response and Scheduling Status Conference

#16 - 04/27/2009 - Facsimile Cover Sheet -- David Salmons et al -- Order Granting Motion for Extension to File Response and Scheduling Status Conference

#17 - 06/01/2009 - Fax -- Participate in the Status Conference (HARD COPY ONLY)

#18 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Cover Letter and Certificate of Service -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#19 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#20 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review -- Exhibit A

#21 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Certification of Indexes to the Administrative Records -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#22 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Honouliuli Index -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#23 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sand Island Index -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#24 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#25 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#26 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#27 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#28 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#29 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#30 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#31 - 05/29/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#32 - 05/29/2009 - Original -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review with Exhibit A - (HARD COPY ONLY)

#33 - 06/01/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA's Region 9's Response to Petiton for Review

#34 - 06/02/2009 - Notification to Participate in the Board's Status Conference

#35 - 06/02/2009 - Fax - Notification to Participate in the Board's Status Conference

#36 - 06/03/2009 - Fax -- Video Conferencing for Tuesday, June 9, 2009

#37 - 06/08/2009 - Original -- Participate in the Status Conference (HARD COPY ONLY)

#38 - 06/12/2009 - Order Denying Stay and Establishing Further Briefing Schedule

#39 - 06/12/2009 - Facsimile Cover Sheet -- David B. Salmons -- et at -- Order Denying Stay and Establishing Further Briefing Schedule

#40 - 06/09/2009 - Transcript from Status Conference held June 9, 2009

#41 - 07/15/2009 - Motion to Supplement Record on Appeal

#42 - 07/15/2009 - Reply Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review

#42.1 - 07/15/2009 - Reply Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review Exhibit 1

#42.2 - 07/15/2009 - Reply Brief in Support of Consolidated Petition for Review Exhibit 2

#43 - 08/31/2010 - Removed and filed in docket NPDES 09-07

#44 - 07/27/2009 - Fax -- Unopposed Motion to File Response to Motion to Supplement Record Concurrently with Surreply Brief

#45 - 08/31/2010 - Removed and filed in Docket NPDES 09-07

#46 - 07/28/2009 - Original -- Unopposed Motion to File Response to Motion to Supplement Record Concurrently with Surreply Brief (HARD COPY ONLY)

#47 - 08/31/2010 - Removed and filed in docket NPDES 09-07

#48 - 08/31/2010 - Removed and filed in docket NPDES 09-07

#49 - 07/30/2009 - Order Granting Motion to File Response to Motion to Supplement Record

#50 - 07/30/2009 - Facsimile Cover Sheet -- David B. Salmons, et at -- Order Granting Motion to File Response to Motion to Supplement Record

#51 - 08/31/2010 - Removed and filed in Docket NPDES 09-07

#52 - 08/31/2010 - Removed and filed in Docket NPDES 09-07

#53 - 08/17/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- EPA Region 9's Surreply in Opposition to Petition for Review, Exhibit A to Surreply, Region 9's Response to Motion to Supplement Record on Appeal and Certificate of Service

#53.1 - 08/17/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Surreply In Opposition to Petition for Review

#53.2 - 08/17/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Exhibit A to Surreply

#53.3 - 08/17/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response to Motion to Supplement Record on Appeal

#54 - 08/17/2009 - Original -- EPA Region 9's Surreply in Opposition to Petition for Review, Exhibit A to Surreply, Region 9's Response to Motion to Supplement Record on Appeal and Certificate of Service

#55 - 08/20/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Missing Pages in Administrative Record

#56 - 08/21/2009 - Original -- Letter stating they has inadvertently omitted two pages from the administrative record for the Sand Island decision (HARD COPY ONLY)

#57 - 09/14/2009 - Request for Oral Argument

#58 - 10/07/2009 - Order Scheduling Oral Argument

#59 - 10/07/2009 - Facsimile Cover Sheet -- David B. Salmons et al -- Order Scheduling Oral Argument

#60 - 11/04/2009 - Fax -- Notification of Counsel for Oral Argument

#61 - 11/13/2009 - Fax - Notification of Counsel for Oral Argument for the City and County of Honolulu

#62 - 11/19/2009 - Transcript from Oral Argument held November 19, 2009 -- pages 1 -- 64

#62.1 - 11/19/2009 - Transcript from Oral Argument held November 19, 2009 Continuation -- pages 65 -- 128

#62.2 - 11/19/2009 - Mini-Script from Oral Argument held November 19, 2009

#63 - 03/29/2010 - Received via CDX Electronic -- New Counsel

#64 - 03/30/2010 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Motion to Supplement Record on Appeal

#64.01 - 03/30/2010 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Motion to Supplemental Record on Appeal - Exhibit 1 (Item A)

#64.02 - 03/30/2010 - Received via CDX Electronc -- Motion to Supplement Record on Appeal - Exhibit 2 (Item B)

#65 - 03/31/2010 - Original - Motion to Supplement Record on Appeal (HARD COPY ONLY)

#66 - 04/13/2010 - Received via CDX Electronic - Cover Letter and Certificate of Service for EPA Region 9's Response to Motion to Supplement Record on Appeal

#66.01 - 04/13/2010 - Received via CDX Electronc - Response to Motion to Supplemt Record on Appeal

#67 - 06/30/2010 - Order Scheduling Status Conference

#68 - 06/30/2010 - Facsimile Cover Sheet - David B. Salmons et al - City & County of Honolulu Sand Island Wastewater Treatment Plant Honouliuli Wastewater Treatment Plant

#69 - 07/06/2010 - Joint Status Report

#70 - 07/12/2010 - Fax - Attendance at the July 19, 2010, Status Conference

#71 - 07/12/2010 - Order Regarding Status Conference

#72 - 07/12/2010 - Facsimile Cover Sheet - David B. Salmons et al - City & County of Honolulu Sand Island Wastewater Treatment Plant Honouliuli Wastewater Treatment Plant

#73 - 07/13/2010 - Fax - Participating in the July 19, 2010, Status Conference

#74 - 07/16/2010 - Cover Letter of an unsigned Consent Decree between the City and County of Honolulu, the United States and other parties

#75 - 07/16/2010 - Consent Decree Part 1 of 5

#76 - 07/16/2010 - Unsigned Consent Decree Part 2 of 5

#77 - 07/16/2010 - Unsigned Consent Decree Part 3 of 5

#78 - 07/16/2010 - Unsigned Consent Decree Part 4 of 5

#79 - 07/16/2010 - Unsigned Consent Decree Part 5 of 5

#80 - 07/16/2010 - EPA Region 9 Supplement to July 6, 2010 Joint Status Report

#81 - 07/19/2010 - Original - Cover Letter of an Unsigned Consent Decree between the City and County of Honolulu, the United States and other parties and EPA Region 9 Supplement to July 6, 2010 Joint Status Report (HARD COPY ONLY)

#82 - 07/19/2010 - Original - Attendance at the July 19, 2010, Status Conference (HARD COPY ONLY)

#83 - 07/19/2010 - Original - Participating in the July 19, 2010, Status Conference (HARD COPY ONLY)

#84 - 07/22/2010 - Request for Stay of Proceedings

#85 - 07/22/2010 - Region 9 Response to Motion for Stay of Proceedings

#86 - 07/22/2010 - Corrected Certificate of Service

#87 - 07/19/2010 - Transcript --- Status Conference held on July 19, 2010

#88 - 08/31/2010 - Removed and filed in Docket NPDES 09-07

#89 - 08/16/2010 - Order Denying Stay of Proceedings

#90 - 08/16/2010 - Facsimile Cover Sheet - David Salmons et al - Order Denying Stay of Proceedings

#91 - 08/20/2010 - Order -- United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit temporary stay

#92 - 08/24/2010 - Order --- United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit -- temporary stay

#93 - 09/02/2010 - Order -- United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit temporary stay pending briefing

#94 - 10/01/2010 - Joint Status Report

#95 - 01/05/2011 - Notice of Withdrawal of Petition for Review

#96 - 02/02/2011 - Order Dismissing Petition for Review

#97 - 02/02/2011 - Facsimile Cover Sheet - David B. Salmons et al - Order Dismissing Petition for Review

Print Index

City and County of Honolulu's Sand Island Wastewater Treatment Plant; City and County of Honolulu's Honouliuli Wastewater Treatment Plant

Index of Filings

Environmental Appeals Board