US EPA Office of Administrative Law Judges



Case Index for CWA-07-2019-0262 - Adamas Construction and Development Services, PLLC and Nathan Pierce

07/05/2025 11:15:44 AM


Filing #: 1 - 09/06/2019 - Complaint and Notice of Opportunity for Hearing

Filing #: 2 - 10/16/2019 - Answer and Request for Hearing

Filing #: 3 - 10/16/2019 - Request for Assignment to ALJ

Filing #: 4 - 10/18/2019 - Order of Designation

Filing #: 5 - 10/18/2019 - Prehearing Order

Filing #: 6 - 11/07/2019 - Complainants Preliminary Statement

Filing #: 7 - 11/07/2019 - Joint Status Report

Filing #: 8 - 11/07/2019 - Complainants Entry of Appearance (E. Huston)

Filing #: 9 - 11/26/2019 - Complainants Initial Prehearing Exchange

Filing #: 9.01 - 05/28/2025 - CX1

Filing #: 9.02 - 05/28/2025 - CX2

Filing #: 9.03 - 05/28/2025 - CX3

Filing #: 9.04 - 05/28/2025 - CX4

Filing #: 9.05 - 05/28/2025 - CX5

Filing #: 9.06 - 05/28/2025 - CX6

Filing #: 9.07 - 05/28/2025 - CX7

Filing #: 9.08 - 05/28/2025 - CX8

Filing #: 9.09 - 05/28/2025 - CX9

Filing #: 9.10 - 05/28/2025 - CX10

Filing #: 9.11 - 05/28/2025 - CX11

Filing #: 9.12 - 05/28/2025 - CX12

Filing #: 9.13 - 05/28/2025 - CX13

Filing #: 9.14 - 05/28/2025 - CX14

Filing #: 9.15 - 05/28/2025 - CX15

Filing #: 9.16 - 05/28/2025 - CX16

Filing #: 9.17 - 05/28/2025 - CX17

Filing #: 9.18 - 05/28/2025 - CX18

Filing #: 9.19 - 05/28/2025 - CX19

Filing #: 9.20 - 05/28/2025 - CX20

Filing #: 9.21 - 05/28/2025 - CX21

Filing #: 9.22 - 05/28/2025 - CX22

Filing #: 9.23 - 05/28/2025 - CX23

Filing #: 9.24 - 05/28/2025 - CX24

Filing #: 9.25 - 05/28/2025 - CX25

Filing #: 9.26 - 05/28/2025 - CX26

Filing #: 9.27 - 05/28/2025 - CX27

Filing #: 9.28 - 05/28/2025 - CX28

Filing #: 9.29 - 05/28/2025 - CX29

Filing #: 9.30 - 05/28/2025 - CX30

Filing #: 9.31 - 05/28/2025 - CX31

Filing #: 9.32 - 05/28/2025 - CX32

Filing #: 9.33 - 05/28/2025 - CX33

Filing #: 9.34 - 05/28/2025 - CX34

Filing #: 9.35 - 05/28/2025 - CX35

Filing #: 9.36 - 05/28/2025 - CX36

Filing #: 9.37 - 05/28/2025 - CX37

Filing #: 9.38 - 05/28/2025 - CX38

Filing #: 9.39 - 05/28/2025 - CX39

Filing #: 9.40 - 05/28/2025 - CX40

Filing #: 9.41 - 05/28/2025 - CX41

Filing #: 9.42 - 05/28/2025 - CX42

Filing #: 9.43 - 05/28/2025 - CX43

Filing #: 9.44 - 05/28/2025 - CX44

Filing #: 9.45 - 05/28/2025 - CX45

Filing #: 9.46 - 05/28/2025 - CX46

Filing #: 9.47 - 05/28/2025 - CX47

Filing #: 9.48 - 05/28/2025 - CX48

Filing #: 9.49 - 05/28/2025 - CX49

Filing #: 9.50 - 05/28/2025 - CX50

Filing #: 10 - 12/17/2019 - Complainants Motion for Leave to File Amended Complaint

Filing #: 10.01 - 05/21/2025 - Amended Complaint

Filing #: 10.02 - 05/21/2025 - Correspondence with Respondents' Counsel

Filing #: 11 - 12/19/2019 - Complainants Motion for Extension of Time to File Rebuttal PHE

Filing #: 11.01 - 05/28/2025 - Email correspondence

Filing #: 12 - 12/20/2019 - Respondents Mot for Ext of Time to File PHE and Opposition to Cs Mot for Leave to Amend Complaint

Filing #: 12.01 - 05/28/2025 - Attachment to Response Motion

Filing #: 13 - 12/20/2019 - Complainants Response to Rs Mot for Ext ofTime to File PHE and Opposition to Cs Mot for Leave to Amend Complaint

Filing #: 14 - 01/02/2020 - Order on Complainants Motion for Leave to Amend the Complaint and on the Parties Motions for Ext of Time for PHEs

Filing #: 15 - 01/27/2020 - Respondents Initial Prehearing Exchange

Filing #: 15.01 - 05/27/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 1

Filing #: 15.02 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 2

Filing #: 15.03 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 3

Filing #: 15.04 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 4

Filing #: 15.05 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 5

Filing #: 15.06 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 6

Filing #: 15.07 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 7

Filing #: 15.08 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 8

Filing #: 15.09 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 9

Filing #: 15.10 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 10

Filing #: 15.11 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 11

Filing #: 15.12 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 12

Filing #: 15.13 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 13

Filing #: 15.14 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 14

Filing #: 15.15 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 15

Filing #: 15.16 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 16

Filing #: 15.17 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 17

Filing #: 15.18 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 18

Filing #: 15.19 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 19

Filing #: 15.20 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 20

Filing #: 15.21 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 21

Filing #: 15.22 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 22

Filing #: 15.23 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 23

Filing #: 15.24 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 24

Filing #: 16 - 02/05/2020 - Complainants Motion for Ext of Time to File Rebuttal PHE

Filing #: 16.01 - 05/28/2025 - Exhibit 1 for Motion for Extension of Time to file Rebuttal Prehearing Exchange

Filing #: 17 - 02/05/2020 - Order on Complainants Motion for Ext of Time to File Rebuttal PHE

Filing #: 18 - 02/20/2020 - Order to Respondents to Show Cause

Filing #: 19 - 02/24/2020 - Complainants Mot to Reserve the Right to File Rebuttal PHE

Filing #: 20 - 03/05/2020 - Respondents Response to Order to Show Cause

Filing #: 21 - 03/10/2020 - Order on Respondents Response to OtSC & Cs Mot to Reserve the Right to File Rebuttal PHE

Filing #: 22 - 04/03/2020 - Complainants Rebuttal PHE

Filing #: 22.01 - 05/28/2025 - CX42

Filing #: 22.04 - 05/28/2025 - CX51

Filing #: 22.05 - 05/28/2025 - CX52

Filing #: 22.06 - 05/28/2025 - CX53

Filing #: 22.07 - 05/28/2025 - CX54

Filing #: 22.08 - 05/28/2025 - CX55

Filing #: 22.09 - 05/28/2025 - CX56

Filing #: 23 - 05/01/2020 - Complainants Motion for AD as to Liability

Filing #: 23.01 - 05/28/2025 - Memorandum and Points in Support of Complainant's Motion for Accelerated Decision as to Liability

Filing #: 24 - 05/20/2020 - Respondents Motion for Ext of Time to File a Response to Cs Mot for AD as to Liability

Filing #: 25 - 05/21/2020 - Respondents Mot for Leave to File Out of Time a Resp to Cs Mot for AD as to Liability

Filing #: 26 - 05/26/2020 - Order on Respondents Mot for Ext of Time and Rs Mot for Leave to File Ouf ofTime

Filing #: 27 - 06/02/2020 - Respondents Response to Cs Motion for AD on Liability and Memorandum

Filing #: 28 - 06/08/2020 - Complainants Reply to Resp to Mot for AD as to Liability

Filing #: 28.01 - 05/28/2025 - nwpr_fact_sheet_-_overview

Filing #: 28.02 - 05/28/2025 - Complaint Exhibit CX42

Filing #: 28.03 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 2

Filing #: 28.04 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 4

Filing #: 28.05 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 5

Filing #: 28.06 - 05/28/2025 - Respondent Exhibit 18

Filing #: 28.07 - 05/28/2025 - ADAMAS-Response to Motion for Accelerated Decision (5 27 20) (1).pdf

Filing #: 28.08 - 05/28/2025 - COS - RESPONSE TO COMPLAINANT’S MOTION FOR ACCELERATED DECISION ON LIABILITY AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW.pdf

Filing #: 29 - 10/26/2020 - Complainants Mot for Leave to Supplement Complainants PHE

Filing #: 30 - 11/02/2020 - Respondents Resp in Oppos to Cs Mot for Leave to Suppl Cs PHE & Rs XMotion for Default & Dismiss & Mot for Attys Fees

Filing #: 30.01 - 05/28/2025 - CX41

Filing #: 30.02 - 05/28/2025 - 10.19.2020 Email to Respondents and Respondents' Counsel

Filing #: 31 - 11/10/2020 - Complainants Reply to Rs Resp to Mot for Leave to Supp Cs PHE and Response to Rs Cross-Motion for Default and Attys Fees

Filing #: 32 - 11/18/2020 - Respondents Reply to Cs Response to Rs Cross-Motion for Default and Attorneys Fees

Filing #: 32.01 - 05/28/2025 - Affidavit of Erin Kleffner in support of Complainant's Motion to Supplement Prehearing Exchange

Filing #: 33 - 12/15/2021 - Order on Complainants Motion to Suppl. Its PHE and Rs Motions for Default and Attorneys Fees

Filing #: 34 - 04/20/2022 - Order on Complainants Motion for AD and Respondents Request for Dismissal & Additional Discovery

Filing #: 35 - 04/26/2022 - Complainants Notice of Appearance (C. Muehlberger)

Filing #: 36 - 04/27/2022 - Complainants Motion for Extension of Time

Filing #: 37 - 04/28/2022 - Order on Complainants Motion for Extension of Time

Filing #: 38 - 05/03/2022 - Complainants Entry of Appearance (K. Kacsur)

Filing #: 39 - 05/12/2022 - Rrespondents Statement Identifying Periods of Unavailability

Filing #: 40 - 05/13/2022 - Complainants Statement of Unavailability for Hearing

Filing #: 41 - 05/23/2022 - Notice of Hearing Order

Filing #: 42 - 05/23/2022 - Order Scheduling Hearing

Filing #: 43 - 06/10/2022 - Complainants Status Report

Filing #: 44 - 06/23/2022 - Complainants Motion for Video Testimony of James Courtney

Filing #: 45 - 06/23/2022 - Complainants Motion for Additional Discovery

Filing #: 45.01 - 05/28/2025 - Sample Written Deposition of Sheri Bement

Filing #: 46 - 06/24/2022 - Complainants Supplemental Prehearing Exchange

Filing #: 46.01 - 05/28/2025 - CX 57

Filing #: 47 - 06/24/2022 - Complainants Motion to Compel Discovery, Motion in Limine

Filing #: 47.01 - 05/28/2025 - ATP Form - Adamas Construction

Filing #: 47.02 - 05/28/2025 - ATP Form - Pierce

Filing #: 48 - 06/27/2022 - Respondents Supplemental PHE Exhibits

Filing #: 48.01 - 05/28/2025 - Respondents Supplemental Prehearing Exhibits

Filing #: 49 - 06/28/2022 - Order Granting Cs Motion for VideoTestimony and Shortening Time for Responses

Filing #: 50 - 07/06/2022 - Respondents Response in Opposition to Cs Mot for Additional Discovery

Filing #: 51 - 07/08/2022 - Complainants Reply to Rs Response in Opposition of Cs Motion for Additional Discovery

Filing #: 52 - 07/08/2022 - Complainant Status Report

Filing #: 53 - 07/11/2022 - Order on Complainants Motion for Additional Discovery & Motion to Compel Discovery

Filing #: 54 - 07/19/2022 - Respondents Motion for Leave to File Out of Time Rs Motion to Dismiss

Filing #: 54.01 - 05/28/2025 - Motion to Dismiss

Filing #: 55 - 07/19/2022 - Respondents Motion to Dismiss

Filing #: 56 - 07/19/2022 - Complainants Motion for Leave to File Amended Complaint

Filing #: 56.01 - 05/21/2025 - Amended Complaint and Notice of Opportunity for Hearing

Filing #: 57 - 07/19/2022 - Respondents Corrected Motion to Dismiss

Filing #: 58 - 07/21/2022 - Order Denying Respondents Motion for Leave Out of Time & Shortening Time for Response

Filing #: 59 - 07/22/2022 - Complainants Motion to Supplement Cs PHE

Filing #: 59.01 - 05/28/2025 - CX58 - NPDES Permit for Lame Deer POTW

Filing #: 60 - 07/25/2022 - Joint Set of Stipulated Facts Exhibits and or Testimony

Filing #: 61 - 07/26/2022 - Order on Complainants Motion to Supplement Its Prehearing Exchange

Filing #: 62 - 07/28/2022 - Respondents Response to Cs Motion for 2nd Amended Complaint

Filing #: 63 - 08/04/2022 - Order on Complainants Mot for Leave to Amend the Amended Complaint

Filing #: 64 - 08/12/2022 - Complainants Statement of Unavailability for Hearing

Filing #: 65 - 08/19/2022 - Order Rescheduling Hearing

Filing #: 66 - 08/19/2022 - Order Rescheduling Hearing

Filing #: 67 - 08/24/2022 - Respondents Answer to 2nd Amended Complaint

Filing #: 67.01 - 05/28/2025 - RESPODENT’S Exhibit RX10

Filing #: 67.02 - 05/28/2025 - land application sewage sludge PDF

Filing #: 67.03 - 05/28/2025 - plain english guide part503 biosolids rule pdf

Filing #: 68 - 09/01/2022 - Complainants Status Report

Filing #: 69 - 09/13/2022 - Respondents Answer to 2nd Amended Complaint and Request for Hearing (duplicate)

Filing #: 70 - 09/30/2022 - Complainants Status Report

Filing #: 71 - 10/26/2022 - Notice of Virtual Hearing Access With Webex Invite

Filing #: 72 - 11/30/2022 - Order Rescheduling Hearing

Filing #: 73 - 11/30/2022 - Order Rescheduling Hearing

Filing #: 74 - 12/08/2022 - Notice of Hearing Location

Filing #: 75 - 01/20/2023 - Complainants Status Report

Filing #: 76 - 02/08/2023 - Complainants (Redacted) Exhibit 50

Filing #: 77 - 03/03/2023 - Complainants Status Report

Filing #: 78 - 03/24/2023 - Respondents Motion for Leave to File Out of Time

Filing #: 78.01 - 05/28/2025 - Affidavit in support of Motion for Leave to File out of time

Filing #: 79 - 03/24/2023 - Respondents Motion to Continue Scheduled Hearing

Filing #: 80 - 03/29/2023 - Order Granting a Continuance of the Hearing

Filing #: 81 - 04/06/2023 - Complainant's Statement of Unavailability for a Hearing

Filing #: 82 - 04/19/2023 - Order Rescheduling Hearing

Filing #: 83 - 04/19/2023 - Order Rescheduling Hearing

Filing #: 84 - 06/16/2023 - Complainant Status Report

Filing #: 85 - 06/23/2023 - Complainants Motion for Issuance of Subpoenas

Filing #: 86 - 07/13/2023 - Order on Complainants Motion for Witness Subpoena

Filing #: 87 - 09/07/2023 - Hearing Transcript (condensed copy)

Filing #: 88 - 09/21/2023 - Order Scheduling Post-Hearing Submissions

Filing #: 89 - 11/03/2023 - Complainanst Post-Hearing Brief

Filing #: 90 - 12/01/2023 - Respondent Initial Post Hearing Brief

Filing #: 91 - 12/15/2023 - Complainant Reply Post Hearing Brief

Filing #: 92 - 01/02/2024 - Respondents Reply to Complainants Post Hearing Brief

Filing #: 93 - 03/26/2025 - Initial Decision and Order

Filing #: 93.01 - 05/27/2025 - Proof of Service

Filing #: 94 - 05/13/2025 - Courtesy Copy of Complainants Response Brief (in Appeal)