Skip to main content
U.S. flag

An official website of the United States government

Here’s how you know

Dot gov

Official websites use .gov
A .gov website belongs to an official government organization in the United States.

HTTPS

Secure .gov websites use HTTPS
A lock (LockA locked padlock) or https:// means you’ve safely connected to the .gov website. Share sensitive information only on official, secure websites.

  • Environmental Topics
  • Laws & Regulations
  • Report a Violation
  • About EPA

Title

  1. Home
  2. Environmental Appeals Board
  3. Case sort order: (Filings)

Published Decisions: (Filings)

By Statute | Alphabetical | Reverse Chronological | Appeal Number | By Citation


(1168 records in this collection) Click for full-text searchSearch this collection | Search entire database

Appeal NumberFiling NumberDate FiledDescription
1009/30/2013Order Extending Time to File Reply To Region 10's Response Brief
2009/30/2013Order Denying Review
Hide details for NPDES 13-11NPDES 13-11
611/25/2013Domestic Return Receipt
711/25/2013Domestic Return Receipt
511/06/2013Facsimile Cover Sheet Ian Sandison et al
310/30/2013Certificate of Service
110/29/2013Petitioner Petition for Review
210/28/2013Certificat of Service
410/28/2013Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 14-01NPDES 14-01
2202/25/2015Domestic Return Receipt - Robert Cox et al
2102/19/2015Domestic Return Receipt - Fredric P. Andes
2002/04/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Robert D. Cox et al
1901/02/2015Oral Argument Transcript on December 11, 2014
1712/29/2014Petitioner Notice Reply Letter to Region 1 December 22, 2014 letter in Response to the Board Order Requesting Additional Information, dated Dece,ber 11. 2014.
1612/23/2014Petitioner Notice Supplementary Filing Letter
1512/22/2014Supplementary Filing Letter
1412/11/2014Facsimile Cover Sheet - Robert D. Cox, Jr. et al
1112/02/2014Permit Issuer Notice of Counsel Presenting Oral Argument
1212/02/2014Letter to inform that the undersigned will present oral argument on December 11, 2-014
1011/13/2014Facsimile Cover Sheet - Robert D. Cox et al
810/14/2014Brief of Amicus Curiae , National Association of Clean Water Agencies
710/14/2014Petitioners' Reply to Region 1's Response to Petition for Review
309/26/2014Cover Letter
509/26/2014Certified Index to the Administrative Reportr
409/26/2014Region 1's Response to the Petition for Review
609/26/2014Electronic Filing and Certified Mail
209/02/2014ADR offer Letter to R. Cox and K. Moraff
108/27/2014Petition for Review by Upper Blackstone Water Pollution Abatement District and theTowns of Bellingha, Franklin, Millis and Medway, Massachusetts
908/27/2014Order Granting Petitioners' Request for Oral Argument and Scheduling Oral Argument
1308/27/2014Order Requesting Additional Information
1808/27/2014Order Denying Review
Hide details for NPDES 14-02NPDES 14-02
704/22/2015Petitioner Stipulated Motion to Dismiss Appeal
603/31/2015Petitioner Joint Status Report
511/26/2014Letter from Region 6, Director, Water Quality Protection Division, that the contested provisions of NPDES Permit No. NM0028355, i.e., the effluent limitations and monitoring requirements for selenium at permitted Outfall 03A048, are stayed and shall not be subject to judicial review pending final agency action
310/21/2014Stipulation and Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
209/19/2014ADR offer letter to L. Rose, L. Cummings, T. Dolan and R. Curry
109/15/2014Petitioner Los Alamos National Security, LLC and the U.S. Department of Energy Petition for Review
409/15/2014Order Staying Appeal
809/15/2014Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 14-03NPDES 14-03
2310/13/2015Domestic Return Receipt - Order Dismissing Petition for Review
2209/29/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet to B. Smith and M. Stein, Order Dismissing Petition for Review
2009/24/2015Petitioner General Electric Aviation's Motion to Dismiss Petition for Review
1908/28/2015Fifth Joint Settlement Negotiations Status Report
1806/25/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Brooks M. Smith et al
1606/23/2015Fourth Joint Settlement Negotiations Status Report and Motion to Continue the Stay of Permit Appeal Proceedingt
1504/15/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet -- Third Order Extending Stay of Proceedings to M. Stein and B. Smith
1304/14/2015Third Joint Settlement Negotiations Status Report and Motion to Continue the Stay of Permit Appeal Proceeding
1202/20/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet -- Second Order Extending Stay Proceedings-- to B Smith and M. Stein
1002/13/2015Permit Issuer Joint Settlement Negotiations Status Report and Motion to Continue the Stay of this Permit Appeal Proceeding
912/16/2014Facsimile Cover Sheet - Brooks M. Smith et al
712/15/2014Joint Settlement Negotiations Status Report and Motion to Continue the Stay of this Permit Appeal Proceeding
611/18/2014Permit Issuer Notice Parties' Joint Response to EAB Letter Re ADR Program
511/13/2014Facsimile Cover Sheet - Brooks M Smith et al
311/07/2014Joint Motion to Stay Permit Appeal Proceeding
211/05/2014ADR offer Letter to Smith et al
1.0210/31/2014Attachment 2 - Comments of General Electric Aviation on Draft NPDES Permit No. MA0003905
1.0110/31/2014Attachment 1 - NPDEA Permit No. MA0003905 Issued on September 30, 2014
1.0510/31/2014Attachment 5 - February 28, 2001 Alternate Operating Modes Evaluation Report
1.0410/31/2014Attachment 4 - EPA's Response to Comments on Draft NPDES Permit No. MA0003905
1.0310/31/2014Attachment 3 - Fact Sheet for Draft NPDES Permit No. MA0003905
110/30/2014General Electric Aviation Petition for Review
410/30/2014Order Granting Motion to Stay Proceedings
810/30/2014Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
1110/30/2014Second Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
1410/30/2014Third Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
1710/30/2014Fourth Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
2110/30/2014Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 14-04NPDES 14-04
12Order Scheduling Oral Argument
18Order Rescheduling Oral Argument
2901/07/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet to D. Gillespie et al Order Dismissing Petition for Review
2712/29/2015Petitioner Lee Ranch Coal Company Motion to Dismiss Petition for Review
2612/18/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - David Gillespie et al
2412/14/2015Joint 5th Status Report
2310/14/2015Joint Status Report
2208/20/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - David Gillespie et al
2008/14/2015Joint Motion To Stay Proceedings
1907/23/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet David Gillespie et at
1607/16/2015Response by Petitioner Lee Ranch Coal Company to EPA Region 6 Motion to stay
1507/15/2015EPA Region 6 Motion for Stay
1407/02/2015Notification by Petitioner Lee Ranch Coal Company of Appearance for Oral Argument
1307/02/2015Letter to notify that D. Gillespie will be presenting argument on behalf of EPA on July 21, 2015
1105/21/2015Petitioner Reply and Opposition by Lee Ranch Coal Company to Region 6 Response to Petition and Motion to Dismiss or Deny Petition
1005/06/2015Permit Issuer Opposed 1st To Dismiss
804/15/2015Petitioner Joint 3rd Status Report
602/25/2015Joint Second Status Report and Request to Continue Stay
501/30/2015Joint 1st Status Report
311/26/2014Stipulation and Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
211/14/2014ADR offer Letter to P. Duchesneau et al
1.111/04/2014Lee Ranch Coal Company Notice of Errata Regarding Exhibits C and E to Petition for Review (Received in Hard Copy)
111/03/2014Petitioner Lee Ranch Coal Company Petition for Review
411/03/2014Order Granting Joint Motion to Stay Proeedings
711/03/2014Order Continuing Stay Until April 15, 2015
911/03/2014Order Scheduling Briefing
1711/03/2014Order Denying Region Motion to Stay the Proceeding, Postponing Oral Argument, and Scheduling Status Conference
2111/03/2014Order Staying Proceedings
2511/03/2014Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
2811/03/2014Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 15-01NPDES 15-01
905/19/2015Domestic Return Receipt from Saint-Gobain Corporation
704/22/2015Permit Issuer Reflied Exhibit 3 Draft Permit
603/13/2015Permit Issuer Region 1 providing Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions with NPDES Permit
503/13/2015Permit Issuer Retion 1 Certified Index to the Administrative Record
403/13/2015Permit Issuer Region 1 Response to the Petition for Review
303/13/2015Permit Issuer Cover Letter
802/13/2015Order Denying Review
102/13/2015Petitioner CertainTeed Corporation Petition for Review
202/13/2015Received via Fax -- CertainTeed Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 15-02NPDES 15-02
5308/01/2016Joint Unopposed Motion to Dismiss Petitions filed by WESCO Operating Inc., Natural Resources Defense Council, Peer and Phoenix Production Company
5201/12/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al
5011/13/2015Amicus Entry of Appearance
4908/18/2015Petitioner Notice Notice of Change of Counsel
4807/30/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. Marco et al
4606/18/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al
4406/17/2015Wesco Petition for Review
4306/16/2015Unopposed Joint Motion for Stay of Briefing Schedule
4206/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al - Order Staying Proceedings to Allow for ADR
4005/29/2015Joint Notification of Intent to Participate in ADR
3905/27/2015Amicus Notice of Appearance
3605/18/2015Petitioner Opposed For an Extension of Time
3805/18/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet --Order Modifying Briefing Schedule to Peter DeMarco et al.
3505/15/2015Petitioner Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04 and 15-05)
3405/13/2015Permittee Joint Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
1205/12/2015Permittee Notice of Entry of Appearance (NPDES 15-02)
2205/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-03)
2705/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-04)
3305/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-05)
1105/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-02)
2005/04/2015ADR Offer Letter to Kirkwood, Leff and Volk (NPDES 15-03)
905/04/2015ADR Offer Letter to Kirkwood, Leff and Volk (NPDES 15-02)
1905/01/2015Amicus Northern Arapaho Tribe Motion to Intervene (NPDES 15-03)
1704/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-03)
804/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-02)
3104/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-05)
704/30/2015Permittee Unopposed Summary Petition (NPDES 15-02)
1004/30/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-02)
3704/30/2015Order Modifying Briefing Schedule
4104/30/2015Order Staying Proceedings to Allow for ADR
4504/30/2015Order Granting Joint Motion to Stay Briefing Schedule
4704/30/2015Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
5104/30/2015Second Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
5404/30/2015Order Dismissing Petitions for Review
1504/29/2015Petitioner Permittee Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
3004/29/2015Permit Issuer Region 8 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-05)
2504/29/2015Permit Issuer Region 8 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-04)
1604/29/2015Region 8 Motion for Extension of Time to Respond (NPDES 15-03)
604/29/2015Region 8 Motion for Extension of Time to Respond (NPDES 15-02)
2104/29/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-03)
2904/17/2015Alternative Dispute Resolution offer Letter (NPDES 15-05)
2404/17/2015Alternative Dispute Resolution Offer Letter (NPDES 15-04)
1404/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet -- Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review to John C. Martin et al (NPDES 15-03)
504/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review to Kirkwood et al (NPDES 15-02)
2304/14/2015NRDC Petition for Review (NPDES 15-04)
2604/14/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-04)
2804/14/2015Received via Fax Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility Petition for Review (NPDES 15-05)
3204/14/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-05)
204/13/2015Permit Issuer EPA Region 8 Response to Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
1304/13/2015Permittee Phoenix Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
1804/13/2015Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
304/13/2015Wesco Operating, Inc. Certificate of Service received via Fax (NPDES 15-02)
104/08/2015Wesco Operating, Inc. Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
404/08/2015Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-02)
Hide details for NPDES 15-03NPDES 15-03
5308/01/2016Joint Unopposed Motion to Dismiss Petitions filed by WESCO Operating Inc., Natural Resources Defense Council, Peer and Phoenix Production Company
5201/12/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al
5011/13/2015Amicus Entry of Appearance
4908/18/2015Petitioner Notice Notice of Change of Counsel
4807/30/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. Marco et al
4606/18/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al
4406/17/2015Wesco Petition for Review
4306/16/2015Unopposed Joint Motion for Stay of Briefing Schedule
4206/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al - Order Staying Proceedings to Allow for ADR
4005/29/2015Joint Notification of Intent to Participate in ADR
3905/27/2015Amicus Notice of Appearance
3605/18/2015Petitioner Opposed For an Extension of Time
3805/18/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet --Order Modifying Briefing Schedule to Peter DeMarco et al.
3505/15/2015Petitioner Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04 and 15-05)
3405/13/2015Permittee Joint Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
1205/12/2015Permittee Notice of Entry of Appearance (NPDES 15-02)
2205/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-03)
2705/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-04)
3305/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-05)
1105/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-02)
2005/04/2015ADR Offer Letter to Kirkwood, Leff and Volk (NPDES 15-03)
905/04/2015ADR Offer Letter to Kirkwood, Leff and Volk (NPDES 15-02)
1905/01/2015Amicus Northern Arapaho Tribe Motion to Intervene (NPDES 15-03)
1704/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-03)
804/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-02)
3104/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-05)
704/30/2015Permittee Unopposed Summary Petition (NPDES 15-02)
1004/30/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-02)
3704/30/2015Order Modifying Briefing Schedule
4104/30/2015Order Staying Proceedings to Allow for ADR
4504/30/2015Order Granting Joint Motion to Stay Briefing Schedule
4704/30/2015Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
5104/30/2015Second Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
5404/30/2015Order Dismissing Petitions for Review
1504/29/2015Petitioner Permittee Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
3004/29/2015Permit Issuer Region 8 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-05)
2504/29/2015Permit Issuer Region 8 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-04)
1604/29/2015Region 8 Motion for Extension of Time to Respond (NPDES 15-03)
604/29/2015Region 8 Motion for Extension of Time to Respond (NPDES 15-02)
2104/29/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-03)
2904/17/2015Alternative Dispute Resolution offer Letter (NPDES 15-05)
2404/17/2015Alternative Dispute Resolution Offer Letter (NPDES 15-04)
1404/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet -- Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review to John C. Martin et al (NPDES 15-03)
504/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review to Kirkwood et al (NPDES 15-02)
2304/14/2015NRDC Petition for Review (NPDES 15-04)
2604/14/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-04)
2804/14/2015Received via Fax Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility Petition for Review (NPDES 15-05)
3204/14/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-05)
204/13/2015Permit Issuer EPA Region 8 Response to Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
1304/13/2015Permittee Phoenix Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
1804/13/2015Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
304/13/2015Wesco Operating, Inc. Certificate of Service received via Fax (NPDES 15-02)
104/08/2015Wesco Operating, Inc. Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
404/08/2015Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-02)
Hide details for NPDES 15-04NPDES 15-04
5308/01/2016Joint Unopposed Motion to Dismiss Petitions filed by WESCO Operating Inc., Natural Resources Defense Council, Peer and Phoenix Production Company
5201/12/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al
5011/13/2015Amicus Entry of Appearance
4908/18/2015Petitioner Notice Notice of Change of Counsel
4807/30/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. Marco et al
4606/18/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al
4406/17/2015Wesco Petition for Review
4306/16/2015Unopposed Joint Motion for Stay of Briefing Schedule
4206/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al - Order Staying Proceedings to Allow for ADR
4005/29/2015Joint Notification of Intent to Participate in ADR
3905/27/2015Amicus Notice of Appearance
3605/18/2015Petitioner Opposed For an Extension of Time
3805/18/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet --Order Modifying Briefing Schedule to Peter DeMarco et al.
3505/15/2015Petitioner Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04 and 15-05)
3405/13/2015Permittee Joint Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
1205/12/2015Permittee Notice of Entry of Appearance (NPDES 15-02)
2205/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-03)
2705/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-04)
3305/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-05)
1105/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-02)
2005/04/2015ADR Offer Letter to Kirkwood, Leff and Volk (NPDES 15-03)
905/04/2015ADR Offer Letter to Kirkwood, Leff and Volk (NPDES 15-02)
1905/01/2015Amicus Northern Arapaho Tribe Motion to Intervene (NPDES 15-03)
1704/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-03)
804/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-02)
3104/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-05)
704/30/2015Permittee Unopposed Summary Petition (NPDES 15-02)
1004/30/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-02)
3704/30/2015Order Modifying Briefing Schedule
4104/30/2015Order Staying Proceedings to Allow for ADR
4504/30/2015Order Granting Joint Motion to Stay Briefing Schedule
4704/30/2015Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
5104/30/2015Second Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
5404/30/2015Order Dismissing Petitions for Review
1504/29/2015Petitioner Permittee Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
3004/29/2015Permit Issuer Region 8 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-05)
2504/29/2015Permit Issuer Region 8 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-04)
1604/29/2015Region 8 Motion for Extension of Time to Respond (NPDES 15-03)
604/29/2015Region 8 Motion for Extension of Time to Respond (NPDES 15-02)
2104/29/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-03)
2904/17/2015Alternative Dispute Resolution offer Letter (NPDES 15-05)
2404/17/2015Alternative Dispute Resolution Offer Letter (NPDES 15-04)
1404/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet -- Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review to John C. Martin et al (NPDES 15-03)
504/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review to Kirkwood et al (NPDES 15-02)
2304/14/2015NRDC Petition for Review (NPDES 15-04)
2604/14/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-04)
2804/14/2015Received via Fax Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility Petition for Review (NPDES 15-05)
3204/14/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-05)
204/13/2015Permit Issuer EPA Region 8 Response to Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
1304/13/2015Permittee Phoenix Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
1804/13/2015Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
304/13/2015Wesco Operating, Inc. Certificate of Service received via Fax (NPDES 15-02)
104/08/2015Wesco Operating, Inc. Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
404/08/2015Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-02)
Hide details for NPDES 15-05  (Consolidated)NPDES 15-05 (Consolidated)
5308/01/2016Joint Unopposed Motion to Dismiss Petitions filed by WESCO Operating Inc., Natural Resources Defense Council, Peer and Phoenix Production Company
5201/12/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al
5011/13/2015Amicus Entry of Appearance
4908/18/2015Petitioner Notice Notice of Change of Counsel
4807/30/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. Marco et al
4606/18/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al
4406/17/2015Wesco Petition for Review
4306/16/2015Unopposed Joint Motion for Stay of Briefing Schedule
4206/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Peter J. DeMarco et al - Order Staying Proceedings to Allow for ADR
4005/29/2015Joint Notification of Intent to Participate in ADR
3905/27/2015Amicus Notice of Appearance
3605/18/2015Petitioner Opposed For an Extension of Time
3805/18/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet --Order Modifying Briefing Schedule to Peter DeMarco et al.
3505/15/2015Petitioner Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04 and 15-05)
3405/13/2015Permittee Joint Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
1205/12/2015Permittee Notice of Entry of Appearance (NPDES 15-02)
2205/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-03)
2705/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-04)
3305/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-05)
1105/08/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule NPDES 15-02, 15-03, 15-04, and 15-05 to Peter J. DeMarco et al (NPDES 15-02)
2005/04/2015ADR Offer Letter to Kirkwood, Leff and Volk (NPDES 15-03)
905/04/2015ADR Offer Letter to Kirkwood, Leff and Volk (NPDES 15-02)
1905/01/2015Amicus Northern Arapaho Tribe Motion to Intervene (NPDES 15-03)
1704/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-03)
804/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-02)
3104/30/2015Permit Issuer Notification of Stay of Contested Permit Conditions (NPDES 15-05)
704/30/2015Permittee Unopposed Summary Petition (NPDES 15-02)
1004/30/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-02)
3704/30/2015Order Modifying Briefing Schedule
4104/30/2015Order Staying Proceedings to Allow for ADR
4504/30/2015Order Granting Joint Motion to Stay Briefing Schedule
4704/30/2015Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
5104/30/2015Second Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
5404/30/2015Order Dismissing Petitions for Review
1504/29/2015Petitioner Permittee Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
3004/29/2015Permit Issuer Region 8 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-05)
2504/29/2015Permit Issuer Region 8 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-04)
1604/29/2015Region 8 Motion for Extension of Time to Respond (NPDES 15-03)
604/29/2015Region 8 Motion for Extension of Time to Respond (NPDES 15-02)
2104/29/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-03)
2904/17/2015Alternative Dispute Resolution offer Letter (NPDES 15-05)
2404/17/2015Alternative Dispute Resolution Offer Letter (NPDES 15-04)
1404/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet -- Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review to John C. Martin et al (NPDES 15-03)
504/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review to Kirkwood et al (NPDES 15-02)
2304/14/2015NRDC Petition for Review (NPDES 15-04)
2604/14/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-04)
2804/14/2015Received via Fax Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility Petition for Review (NPDES 15-05)
3204/14/2015Order Consolidating Petitions for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule (NPDES 15-05)
204/13/2015Permit Issuer EPA Region 8 Response to Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
1304/13/2015Permittee Phoenix Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
1804/13/2015Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-03)
304/13/2015Wesco Operating, Inc. Certificate of Service received via Fax (NPDES 15-02)
104/08/2015Wesco Operating, Inc. Motion for Extension of Time (NPDES 15-02)
404/08/2015Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review (NPDES 15-02)
Hide details for NPDES 15-06NPDES 15-06
2702/17/2016Joint Status Report Petitioner Motion For Leave To Withdraw The Petition And Joint Motion to Dismiss The Proceedings
2601/12/2016Joint 3rd Status Report
2512/16/2015Joint Status Report
2411/16/2015Joint Status Report
2310/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet to S. Young et al, Fourth Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
2110/09/2015Status Report and Fourth Joint Motion to Stay the Proceedings
1909/22/2015Joint Third Motion to Stay of Proceedings
1809/14/2015Joint Status Report
1607/31/2015Permit Issuer Notice Cover Letter
1507/31/2015Permit Issuer Joint Status Report and Second Motion to Stay the Proceedingst
1207/07/2015Joint Motion to Stay the Proceedings
1107/07/2015Assented to Motion to Withdraw a Portion of the Permit and to Partially Dismiss the Petition for Review as Moot
1007/07/2015EPA Region 1 Cover Letterr Assented to Motion to Withdraw a Portion of the Permit and to Partially Dismiss the Petition as Moot and Joint Motion for Stay
906/12/2015Notice Partial Withdrawal
806/12/2015Cover Letter Notice of Partial Withdrawal
706/12/2015Assented to Motion to Partially Dismiss the Petition for Review as Moot
605/13/2015Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested Conditions
505/13/2015Permit Issuer Certified Index to the Administrative Record
405/13/2015Permit Issuer Cover Letter
305/13/2015Permit Issuer Notice Intent to and/or Modify Portions of the Permit
205/13/2015Permit Issuer Response Brief
104/13/2015Petition for Review of City of Nashua Wastewater Treatment Facility
1304/13/2015Order Granting Stay of Proceedings
1404/13/2015Order Addressing Partial Withdrawal of Permit Conditions and Dismissing Related Permit Challenges as Moot
1704/13/2015Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
2004/13/2015Third Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
2204/13/2015Fourth Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
2804/13/2015Order Dismissing Petition
Hide details for NPDES 15-07NPDES 15-07
2108/19/2015Domestic Return Receipts - Kevin Beaton, Justin Hayes and Douglas Conde
2007/28/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Kevin J. Beaton et al
1807/21/2015EPA Region 10's Motion to Dismisss
1707/21/2015Permit Issuer Notice Notification of Withdrawal of Permit Provisions
1606/19/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet to Beaton, Conde, Hayes, and Weber Order Granting Second Motion for Extension of Time to File Response
1406/18/2015Objection to EPA Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief
1306/17/2015EPA Region 10 Second Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief
1206/16/2015Pro Se on behalf of J. Hayes and the Idaho Conservation League
1106/11/2015ADR Offer Letter to K. Beaton, D. Conde and C. Weber
1005/28/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet --Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time to L. Beaton, D. Conde and C. Weber
805/26/2015Idaho Department of Environmental Quality Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief
705/26/2015Idaho Department of Environmental Quality Notice of Appearance
605/19/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet -- Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time to File Response to K. Beaton and C. Weber
405/15/2015Permit Issuer EPA Region 10 1st For an Extension of Time to File Response Brief
305/06/2015Received via email -- Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions NPDES Permit No ID0023591
205/05/2015Received via email -- Corrected Certificate of Service for Petition for Review
104/28/2015Petitioner Star Sewer and Water District
504/28/2015Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time to File Response
904/28/2015Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time
1504/28/2015Order Granting Second Motion for Extension of Time to File Response
1904/28/2015Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 15-08NPDES 15-08
24Order on Pending Motions and Setting Oral Argument
30Order Rescheduling Oral Argument
38Order Rescheduling Oral Argument for February 18, 2016
40Order Rescheduling Oral Argument for March 1, 2016
6406/20/2016Domestic Return Receipt - J. Hall
6205/26/2016Domestic Return Receipt - J. Hall
6105/13/2016Petitioner/Appellant Motion for Reconsideration of NPDES 15-08 ~ City of Taunton Department of Public Works
5804/20/2016Petitioner Reply on Motion to Remedy Improper Board Member Introduction of New Permit Appeal Issues and Burden of Proof and Request for Removal of Presiding Judge Ward Due to Bias
5704/20/2016Petitioner Reply in Support of its Motion to Supplement the Record
5504/14/2016Region's Response to Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record
5604/14/2016Region's Response to Motion to Remedy Bias
5404/14/2016Region's Cover Letter to Responses filed Apr. 14, 2016
5304/07/2016City of Taunton Motion to Supplement the Record with the Draft NPDES Permit for Nashua, New Hampshire
5204/06/2016Petitioner Motion to Remedy Improper Board Member Introduction of New Permit Appeal Issues and Burden of Proof, and Request for Recusal of Presiding Judge Ward Due to Bias
5103/28/2016Petitioner's Reply to EPA's Response to City's Motion to Strike and to Supplement the Administrative Record
5003/22/2016EPA Region 1 Response to the City of Taunton Motion to Strike and to Supplement the Administrative Record
4903/17/2016Petitioner Motion to Strike False and Misleading Testimony on the Record and to supplement the Administrative Record with Deposition Testimony on These Issues
5903/15/2016Oral Argument Transcript held on March 1, 2016
4803/08/2016City of Taunton Reply to EPA Region 1 Response to City Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record
4703/04/2016EPA Region 1 Response to the City of Taunton Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record
4603/04/2016Order Rescheduling Oral Argument for March 1, 2016, dated February 13, 2016 addressed to J.C. Hall was Return to Sender Not Deliverable as Addressed Unable to Forward
4502/29/2016Petitioner 1st City of Taunton Motion to supplement the Administrative Record
4402/25/2016Petitioner Notice City of Taunton's Errata
4202/23/2016Order Rescheduling Oral Argument for February 18, 2016, dated February 8, 2016 addressed to J.C. Hall was Return to Sender Not Deliverable as Addressed Unable to Forward
4302/23/2016Order Granting City of Taunton Permission to Display Certain Materials by Powerpoint During Oral Argument dated February 3, 2016 addressed to J.C. Hall was Return to Sender Not Deliverable as Addressed Unable to Forward
4102/19/2016Order Establishing Deadline for the Region Response to Petitioner Motion to Display Excerpts of the Record During Oral Argument, Dated January 28, 2016, addressed to J. C. Hall was "Returned To Sender Not Deliverable As Addressed Unable to Forward"
3902/11/2016City of Taunton Unopposed Motion to Reschedule Oral Argument
3702/08/2016Letter received via email -- add one additional name to list of attendees for oral argument
3502/02/2016Petitioner 1st City of Taunton Reply in Support of Petitioner Unopposed Motion to Use PowerPoint to Display Excerpts of the Record During Oral Argument
3402/01/2016EPA Region 1's Response to "Petitioner's Unopposed Motion to Allow Use of Powerpoint To Display Excerpts of the Record During Oral Argument
3302/01/2016Notice of Counsel Attending Argument
3101/27/2016Petitioner Unopposed Motion to Allow Use of PowerPoint to Display Excerpts of the Record During Oral Argument
2901/14/2016Notice Participating Counsel
2801/12/2016Petitioner Notice of Counsel Presenting Oral Argument
2611/04/2015City of Taunton Motion for Partial Reconsideration of Board Order on Pending Motions and Setting Oral Argument
2511/04/2015Response to Board Order
2309/30/2015EPA Region 1's Reply to Petitioner's Response to the Motion to Strike
2209/09/2015Petitioner Response in Opposition to Respondent Motion to Strike Certain Attachments
2008/19/2015Petitioner Notice Certificate of Service
1908/19/2015Petitioner's Reply in Support of it's Motion for the Appointment of a Technical Advisor/Expert
2108/19/2015City of Tauton's Response to EPA's Opposition to the Moton to Supplement the Administrative Record
1808/06/2015Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1 Amendment to Certified Index to the Administrative Record
1708/06/2015Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1 Notice of Filing Amended Certified Index to the Administrative Record
1608/06/2015Permit Issuer EPA Region 1 Opposition to the Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record
1508/06/2015Permit Issuer EPA Region 1 Opposition to the City of Taunton Motion for the Appointment of a Technical Advisor
1408/06/2015Permit Issuer EPA Region 1 Motion to Strike Certain Attachments to Petitioner City of Taunton Reply
1308/06/2015Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1 Cover Letter
1207/16/2015ADR Offer Letter
1007/10/2015Joint Unopposed Motion to Modify the Response and Reply Deadlines for Petitioner Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record and Motion to Appoint a Technical Advisor Expert and motion to Set the Deadlines for EPA Motion to Strike
907/09/2015Petitioner Motion for the Appointment of a Technical Advisor Expert
807/08/2015City of Taunton's Motion to supplement the Administrative Record
706/30/2015City of Taunton Wastewater Treatment Plant Reply in Support of its Petition for Review of NPDES Permit Issued by Region 1
606/12/2015Notice Uncontested and Severable Conditions
506/12/2015Certified Index to the Administrative Record
406/12/2015EPA Region 1 Response to the Petition for Review
306/12/2015EPA Region 1 Cover Letter
206/12/2015EPA Region 1 Cover Letter
105/13/2015Petitioner City of Taunton Petition for Review
1105/13/2015Order Granting Joint Unopposed Motion to Modify and Set Filing Deadlines
2705/13/2015Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration
3205/13/2015Order Establishing Deadline for the Regions Response to Petitioner Motion to Display Excerpts of the Record During Oral Argument
3605/13/2015Order Granting City of Taunton Permission to Display Certain Materials by Powerpoint During Oral Arugment
6005/13/2015Order Denying Review
6305/13/2015Order Denying Reconsideration
6505/13/2015City of Taunton v. EPA
Hide details for NPDES 15-09NPDES 15-09
909/03/2015Domestic Return Receipt, W. Taylor
707/31/2015Permit Issuer Notice Cover Letter
607/31/2015Permit Issuer Assented to Motion to Dismiss the Petition for Review as Moot
507/31/2015Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal and Uncontested Conditions
407/30/2015Notice of Partial Withdrawal and Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions
307/16/2015ADR Offer Letter
207/08/2015Certificate of Service
107/06/2015Brattle Road Farm Condominium Trust Petition for Review
807/06/2015Order Dismissing Petition as Moot
Hide details for NPDES 15-10NPDES 15-10
2804/21/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet - S. Jaffe et al
2604/19/2016Joint Unopposed Invensys Systems Inc. Motion for Leave to Withdraw the Petition and Joint Motion to Dismiss the Proceedings
2504/06/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al
2303/31/2016Permit Issuer Joint Status Report
2203/03/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al
2003/01/2016Joint Status Report and Fourth Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time
1901/11/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al
1701/08/2016Joint Supplemental 3rd Status Report
1601/07/2016Facsimile Cover sheet to S. Jaffe et at Order Requiring Supplemental Status Report
1401/04/2016Status Report and Third Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time
1311/05/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al
1111/02/2015Status Report and Second Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time
1009/16/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe et al
809/15/2015Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time
709/04/2015Petition for Review of the Invensys Systems NPDES Permit Issued by EPA Region 1
608/06/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet -- to Seth D. Jaffe et al -- Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
408/03/2015Permit Issuer Opposition to Motion for Extension of Time
307/30/2015Facsimile Cover Sheet - Seth D. Jaffe, Esq.
107/29/2015Invensys Systems, Motion for Extension of Time-- Received via FedEx Express Priority Overnight Mail
207/29/2015Order Directing Response to Motion for Extension of the Time to File Petition
507/29/2015Order Granting Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
907/29/2015Order Granting Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time to File Response
1207/29/2015Second Order Granting Motion for Stay Proceediings and Extension of Time to File Response
1507/29/2015Order Requiring Supplemental Status Report
1807/29/2015Third Order Granting Motion for Stay of Proceedings and Extension of Time to File Response
2107/29/2015Order Granting Fourth Joint Motion for Stay of Procedeedings and Extension of Time to File Response
2407/29/2015Order Directing the Parties to File a Further Joint Status Report by
April 27, 2016
2707/29/2015Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 15-11NPDES 15-11
1001/11/2016Town of Salisbury Motion for Leave to Withdraw the Petition and Joint Motion to Dismiss the Proceedings
812/08/2015Joint Unopposed Third Motion to Stay the Proceedings
611/04/2015Second Joint Motion to Stay the Proceedings
510/13/2015Joint Status Report
309/02/2015Permit Issuer Joint Motion to Stay the Proceedings
208/14/2015ADR Offer Letter to W. Taylor et al
108/13/2015Town of Salisbury Sewer Commission Petition for Review
1.0208/13/2015Attachment 2 -- February 2011 Ammonia Nitrogen Removal Engineering Report Prepared by Weston & Sampson
1.0108/13/2015Attachment 1 -- July 13 2011 Administrative Order Document No. 11 012
1.0508/13/2015Attachment 5 --May 2 2014 Letter fro D. Dart to N. Harrington Salisbury Town Manager
1.0808/13/2015Attachment 8 -- February 10 2015 Comments of Christopher M. Perkins PE Weston & Sampson on Behalf of the Town
1.0608/13/2015Attachment 6 --July 31 2014 Scope of Work with Cover Letter to G. Harding EPA and K. Brander MassDEP
1.0308/13/2015Attachment 3 -- January 2013 Copper Optimization Engineering Report, Prepared by Weston & Sampson
1.0408/13/2015Attachment 4 -- January 2015 Quarterly Progress Report
1.0708/13/2015Attachment 7 -- April 14 2015 Letter from D. Dart to N. Harrington
408/13/2015Order Granting Stay of Proceedings
708/13/2015Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
908/13/2015Order Granting Third Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
1108/13/2015Order Dismissing Petition
Hide details for NPDES 15-12NPDES 15-12
1607/07/2016Petitioner Assented to Motion for Leave to Withdraw its Petition and Joint Motion to Dismiss the Proceedings
1507/05/2016Joint 5th Status Report
1406/03/2016Fourth Joint Status Report
1203/29/2016Third Joint Status Report and Motion to Further Continue the Stay of the Proceedings
1002/12/2016Joint Unopposed 3rd For an Extension of Time
812/15/2015Joint Status Report and Motion to Continue the Current Stay of the Proceedings
712/08/2015Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions, Received via email and electronic filing
612/08/2015Filing of Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions, Received via email and electronic filing
411/12/2015Joint Unopposed Motion to stay the Proceedings
311/06/2015ADR Offer Letter to V. Moore et al
111/04/2015Sterling Suffolk Racecourse Petition for Review
511/04/2015Order Granting Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
911/04/2015Order Granting Joint Motion to Continue the Current Stay of Proceedings
1111/04/2015Second Order Granting Joint Motion to Continue the Current Stay of Proceedings
1311/04/2015Third Order Granting Joint Motion to Continue the Current Stay of Proceedings
1711/04/2015Order Dismissing Petition for Review
211/04/2015Email from V. Moore requesting the Board to delete three duplicate attachments Filing ID PINT A3XQYV that were filed electronically
Hide details for NPDES 16-01NPDES 16-01
2104/05/2017Motion For Voluntary Dismissal of Petition
2004/04/2017Fascimile Cover Sheet - M. Gildea
1804/03/2017Status Report and Third Joint Motion for Further Stay of the Proceedings
1703/22/2017Facsimile Cover Sheet - B. Corman et at
1503/21/2017Status Report and Joint Motion for Further Stay of the Proceedings
1403/20/2017Status Report and Joint Motion for Further Stay of the Proceedings
1302/07/2017Facsimile Cover Sheet - M. Gildea et al
1102/06/2017Status Report and Joint Motion for Further Stay of the Proceedings t
912/08/2016Town Reply to EPA Response to Town's Motion to Stay and Request for Oral Argument
812/07/2016Permit Issuer EPA Region 1's Response to the Town of Bridgewater's Motion for Stay and for an Accelerated Ruling Thereonr
712/05/2016Notice of Appearance, Motion for Stay and For Accelerated Decision, and Request for Oral Argument
611/30/2016Permit Issuer, EPA Region 1's, Reply to the Town of Bridgewater's Opposition to EPA Region 1's Motion to Dismiss the Petition
411/22/2016Facsimile Cover Sheet - M. Gildea et al
511/22/2016The Town of Bridgewater's Opposition to EPA Region 1's Motion to Dismiss the Town's Petition
1.0111/17/2016Attachment A Letter from Town of Bridgewater reviewed the Draft NPDES permit
111/17/2016Bridgewater Petition for Review
1.0211/17/2016Attachment B NPDES Permit
1.0911/17/2016Attachment E Draft Permit
1.0511/17/2016Attachment D Comprehensive Wastewater Management Plan with Water Resources
1.111/17/2016Attachment F Fact Sheet
1.0311/17/2016Letter to C. Kane, Final NPDES permit issued Part 1 of 2
1.0411/17/2016Letter to C. Kane, Final NPDES permit issued Part 2 of 2
1.0711/17/2016Attachment D Comprehensive Wastewater Management Plan with Water Resources Cont'd
1.0811/17/2016Attachment D Comprehensive Wastewater Management Plan with Water Resources Cont'd
1.0611/17/2016Attachment D Comprehensive Wastewater Management Plan with Water Resources Cont'd
311/17/2016Order Directing Filing of Response to Motion and Staying Other Deadlines
1011/17/2016Order on Motion for Stay and for Accelerated Decision and Request for Oral Argument
1211/17/2016Order Granting Joint Motion for Further Stay of Proceedings
1611/17/2016Order Granting Second Joint Motion for Further Stay of Proceedings
1911/17/2016Order Granting Third Joint Motion for Further Stay of Proceedings
2211/17/2016Order Granting Petitioner's Motion and Dismissing Petition for Review
211/15/2016EPA Region 1 Motion to Dismiss the Petition as Untimely and to Stay the Filing of the Response to Petition and Certified Index of the Administrative Record
Hide details for NPDES 17-01NPDES 17-01
910/25/2017Petitioner 1st Unopposed Buzzards Bay Coalition's Motion to Withdraw its Petition and Dismiss its Appeal
306/01/2017Joint Notice of Intent to Participate in the Alternative Dispute Resolution Program
205/18/2017ADR Offer with enclosure to M. Chertok and C. Dierker
105/15/2017Petitioner, Buzzards Bay Coalition, Petition for Review
405/15/2017Order Staying Proceedings to Allow Parties to Participate in ADR
505/15/2017Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
605/15/2017Order Further Extending Stay of Proceedings
705/15/2017Third Order Staying Proceedings
805/15/2017Fourth Order Staying Proceedings
1005/15/2017Order Dismissing Petitions for Review
Hide details for NPDES 17-02NPDES 17-02
910/25/2017Petitioner 1st Motion for Voluntary Dismissal of Petition
306/01/2017Joint Notice of Intent to Participate in ADR
205/18/2017ADR Offer Letter with enclosure to M. J. Connolly and C. Dierker
105/15/2017Petitioner, the Town of Marion, Petition for Review
405/15/2017Order Staying Proceedings to Allow Parties to Participate in ADR
505/15/2017Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
605/15/2017Order Further Extending Stay of Proceedings
705/15/2017Third Order Staying Proceedings
805/15/2017Fourth Order Staying Proceedings
1005/15/2017Order Dismissing Petitions for Review
Hide details for NPDES 17-03NPDES 17-03
19Order Scheduling Oral Argument
21Order Staying Appeal and Rescheduling Oral Aargument
23Second Order Extending Stay of Proceedings and Rescheduling Oral Argument
3111/29/2018Permit Issuer Respondent EPA Region 6 Reply to Petitioner Memorandum Brief in Opposition to the EPA Motion to Supplement the Administrative RecordBrief
3211/20/2018Oral Argument transcript on October 30, 2018
3011/13/2018Petitioner Response Brief
2911/08/2018Respondent EPA Region 6 Notice of Filing of a Copy of the Final Permit Issued in 2000 for the Ruidoso WWTP and Opposed Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record
2710/30/2018Permit Issuer Respondent EPA Region 6 Opposed Motion to Supplement the Administrative Record
2510/16/2018Received via Email Permittee City of Ruidoso Downs and Village of Ruidoso will be attending Oral Argument in Person
2610/16/2018Received via Email Petitioner will present Oral Argument
2410/15/2018Received via Email Notification of Counsel at Oral Argument
2004/26/2018Joint Unopposed Motion to Reschedule June 14, 2018 Oral Argument 1st
1803/05/2018Petitioner Reply Brief
1702/14/2018Letter from Region 6 enclosed four CDs each containing a copy of the Administrative Record.
1601/18/2018Permittee Notice of Appearance by the Village of Ruidoso and the City of Ruidoso Downs and Response to Petition for Review
1501/18/2018Permit Issuer EPA Region 6's Response Brief to the Petition for Review
1311/14/2017Joint Supplement to Joint Motion by all Parties for an EAB Order Establishing a Revised Briefing Schedule and Joint Notice by all Parties of Agreement to Electronic Service Between all Parties
1111/07/2017Joint Unopposed Motion 2nd Time By all Parties for an EAB Order Establishing a Revised Briefing Schedule and Joint Notice by all Parties of Agreement to Electronic Service between all Parties
1010/24/2017Petitioner Notice of Withdrawal of Filing (Nos. 7 and 8 on Index of Filings)
810/24/2017Duplicate Filing Removed (See Filing #10)
710/24/2017Duplicate Filing Removed (See Filing #10)
910/16/2017Notice of Address of Attorney for Permittees
610/12/2017Petitioner Memorandum Brief in Support of Petition for Review
510/10/2017ADR Offer Letter to E. Kendrick, Esq. Return to Sender, Attempted, Not Known Unable to Forward Return to Sender
409/26/2017ADR Offer Letter to S. Sugarman, D. Gillespie, and E. Kendrick
108/22/2017Petition for Review
208/22/2017Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time
308/22/2017Order Granting Extension of Time To File Opening Brief
1208/22/2017Order on Briefing Schedule
1408/22/2017Order Granting Joint Motion to Establish a Revised Briefing Schedule
2208/22/2017Order Extending Stay of Proceedings
2808/22/2017Order on Briefing Schedule and Submission of Permit Document
3308/22/2017Order Denying Review
3408/22/2017Rio Hondo Land & Cattle Co., L.P. v. United States Env't Prot. Agency
Hide details for NPDES 17-04NPDES 17-04
1611/14/2017Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bostic
1711/13/2017Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bailey
1310/11/2017Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bailey
1410/10/2017Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bostic
1210/03/2017Domestic Return Receipt - D. Montgomery
1110/02/2017Motion for Reconsideration or Clarification with Attachment and Certification of Service
1009/28/2017Domestic Return Receipt - D. Montgomery
709/25/2017J. Bailey Motion for Reconsideration or Clarification
909/25/2017Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bailey
809/25/2017Domestic Return Receipt - J. Bostic
409/12/2017Email Correspondence between Jill Bailey and Clerk of the Board from August 29, 2017 to September 12, 2017
209/06/2017J. Bailey Petition for Review
109/05/2017Petition for Review Cover Letter
309/05/2017Petition for Review Certificate of Service
509/05/2017Order Dismissing Petition for Lack of Jurisdiction
609/05/2017Corrected Order Dismissing Petition for Lack of Jurisdiction and Establishing Deadline
1509/05/2017Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration or Clarification
Hide details for NPDES 17-05NPDES 17-05
10Order Scheduling Oral Argument
2104/04/2018Domestic Return Receipt - L. Lovejoy
1903/27/2018Domestic Return Receipt - S. DeRoma et al
2003/27/2018Domestic Return Receipt - J. Block
1802/28/2018Oral Argument Transcript on February 22, 2018
1602/27/2018Petitioner Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety Post-Argument Submission Pursuant to 40 C.F.R. Section 124.2 and 124.5(b)
1502/27/2018Permittees Response to Request from Oral Argument received via FedEx.and email
1402/06/2018Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety Notice of Intent to Appear and Present Oral Argument
1302/05/2018Permit Issuer Notice Designation of Attorney Presenting Oral Argument
1202/02/2018Counsel will be Present for Oral Argument
911/03/2017Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety Reply Submission Pursuant to 40 C.F.R. Section 124.2 and 124.5(b)
810/18/2017EPA Response to Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety's Informal Appeal of EPA's Denial of Request to Terminate Permit Authorization
710/16/2017Response to Order for Additional Briefing dated September 21, 2017
609/27/2017ADR Offer Letter to J. Block et al with enclosure
409/22/2017Facsimile - Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time and Order Granting Extension of Time to File Response
209/18/2017Letter to W. Honker and J. Payne Requesting a Response that Addresses the Petitioner Petition for Review
109/14/2017Petitioner Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety Petition for Review
309/14/2017Order for Additional Briefing
509/14/2017Order Extending Time for Additional Briefing
1109/14/2017Order Allocating Time for Oral Agrument
1709/14/2017Final Decision
2209/14/2017Concerned Citizens for Nuclear Safety, Inc. v. EPA
Hide details for NPDES 17-06NPDES 17-06
901/09/2018Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st To Dismiss
801/09/2018Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal
710/30/2017Facsimile Cover Sheet - M. Nykiel et al
510/26/2017EPA Region 10's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief
410/25/2017Permit Issuer Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions
310/25/2017ADR Offer Letter to M. Nykiel and A. Stern
210/10/2017Received via Federal Express Certificate of Service confirming service by Federal Express Mail to the Regional Administrator for EPA Region 10 and the Permit Applicant
110/06/2017Petitioner Petition for Review
610/06/2017Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time to File Response to Petition for Review
1010/06/2017Order Dismissing Petition for Review as Moot
Hide details for NPDES 17-07NPDES 17-07
1001/23/2018Domestic Return Receipt - M. Gorski
901/23/2018Domestic Return Receipt - G. Morand
712/28/2017Joint Unopposed To Dismiss
512/11/2017Joint 1st Status Report
311/01/2017Permit Issuer Joint Unopposed 1st Motion To Stay
210/19/2017ADR Offer Letter to G. Morand, C. Dierker, and M. Gorski
110/16/2017Barnhardt Manufacturing Company Petition for Review
410/16/2017Order Granting Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings
610/16/2017Order Continuing Stay of Proceedings
810/16/2017Order Dismissing Petition
Hide details for NPDES 17-08NPDES 17-08
5.0211/29/2019U.S. EPA Region 1 Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions
1905/04/2018Motion for Voluntary Dismissal of Petition for Review received via Electronic Filing and Overnight Mail
1704/18/2018Joint 5th MotionTo Continue Stay
1503/28/2018Joint 4th To Continue Stay
1303/15/2018Third Joint MotionTo Continue Stay
1203/08/2018Fourth Joint Status Report
1002/09/2018Joint 3rd Status Report
902/08/2018Joint 3rd Status Report
701/08/2018Joint 2nd Status Report and Motion to Continue the Stay
612/08/2017First Joint Status Report and Acknowledgement of Consent to Electronic Service
511/29/2017Permit Issuer Notice Uncontested and Severable Conditions Cover Letter and Certificate of Service
411/13/2017Order Granting Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings
311/07/2017Joint 1st Motion To Stay The Proceedings
210/30/2017ADR Offer Letter to W. Taylor et al
110/27/2017Petitioner Town of Fairhaven Petition for Review
810/27/2017Order Granting Second Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings
1110/27/2017Order Continuing Stay of Proceedings
1410/27/2017Order Granting Joint Motion to Continue Stay of Proceedings
1610/27/2017Order Granting Joint Motion to Continue Stay of Proceedings
1810/27/2017Order Granting Joint Motion to Continue Stay of Proceedings
2010/27/2017Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 18-01NPDES 18-01
1510/24/2018Petitioner Reply Brief
1409/24/2018Idaho Department of Environmental Quality Response to Idaho Conservation League Petition for Review
1309/24/2018Permit Issuer EPA Region 10 Excerpts of the Administrative Record
1209/24/2018Permit Issuer EPA Region 10 Certification and Index to the Administrative Record
1109/24/2018Permit Issuer Region 10 Response Brief
1008/30/2018Certificate of Service to Idaho Department of Environmental Quality of Order Granting Extension of Time
808/17/2018ICLs Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Reply Brief
708/06/2018Permit Issuer Notice Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions
507/30/2018EPA Region 10s Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief
407/27/2018Idaho Department of Environmental Quality's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief
307/27/2018Idaho Department of Environmental Quality's Notice of Appearance
207/25/2018ADR Offer Letter
107/12/2018Petitioner Petition for Review
607/12/2018Order Granting Extension of Time and Addressing Service by Email
907/12/2018Order Granting Extension of Time for Filing of Reply
1607/12/2018Order Denying Review
Hide details for NPDES 18-02NPDES 18-02
2712/19/2018Region IX Motion to Dismiss
2612/19/2018Region IX Notice of Permit Withdrawal
2411/02/2018Appellants Response to Order for Clarification
2311/02/2018Region IXs Response to Order Directing Parties to Provide Further Clarification
2211/02/2018Arizona Public Serivce Company's Response to Order Directing Parties to Provide Further Clarification
2010/23/2018Permit Issuer Reply Brief Attachments with Certificate of Service
1910/22/2018Permit Issuer Reply Brief
1810/22/2018Arizona Public Service Company's Reply in Support of Region IX's Motion to Partially Dismiss Petition for Review; Motion to Establish Revised Briefing Schedule
1710/17/2018Petitioner Amended Notice of Appearance
1610/17/2018Petitioner Response Brief
1510/16/2018Petitioner Notice of Appearance
1410/16/2018Petitioner Notice of Appearance
1210/10/2018Permittee Notice APS's Response to Region IX's Motion to Partially Dismiss Petition for Review; Motion to Establish Revised Briefing Schedule
1110/10/2018Permittee Notice of Appearance
1010/09/2018Permit Issuer Opposed Other
910/09/2018Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal and Revised Notice of Stayed Provisions
808/28/2018Permit Issuer Notice Stay of Permit Pending Appeal
708/27/2018Permit Issuer Notice Declining ADR
508/09/2018Region 9 Supplement to its Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Responses and Replies
308/01/2018Permit Issuer Unopposed For Extension of Time to File Responses and Replies
207/26/2018ADR Offer Letter
107/16/2018Petitioner Petition for Review
407/16/2018Order Regarding Request for Extension of Time and Service by Email
607/16/2018Order Granting Extension of Time to File Responses and Reply
1307/16/2018Order Establishing Response and Reply Deadlines to Region Motion to Partially Dismiss Petition for Review and Revise Briefing Schedule
2107/16/2018Order Directing Parties to Provide Further Clarification
2507/16/2018Order Partially Dismissing Petition for Review and Establishing Briefing Schedule
2807/16/2018Order Regarding Response to Region Motion to Dismiss
2907/16/2018Order Dismissing Petition for Review as Moot
Hide details for NPDES 18-03NPDES 18-03
1210/19/2018Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st To Dismiss
1110/15/2018Permit Issuer 3rd Status Report
1010/15/2018Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal
809/11/2018Joint 1st Status Report
708/28/2018Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested Permit Conditions
608/27/2018Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested Permit Conditions
508/16/2018Joint Acknowledgement of Consent to Service by Electronic Mail
308/12/2018Joint Motion to Stay the Proceedings
208/02/2018ADR Offer Letter
107/18/2018Petitioner Petition for Review
407/18/2018Order Granting Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings
907/18/2018Order Continuing Stay of Proceedings and Further Order Regarding Service by E-mail
1307/18/2018Order Dismissing Petition for Review as Moot
Hide details for NPDES 18-04NPDES 18-04
910/29/2018Domestic Return Receipt K. Walker
810/24/2018Domestic Return Receipt M. Nykiel
610/10/2018Permit Issuer EPA Region 10 Motion to Dismiss
408/20/2018Joint Motion for Extension of Time to File Response and Reply Brief
308/14/2018Permit Issuer Notice Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions
208/03/2018ADR Offer Letter
107/26/2018Petitioner Petition for Review
507/26/2018Order Granting Extensions of Time to File Response and Reply Briefs and Addressing Service by Email
707/26/2018Order Dismissing Petition for Review as Moot
Hide details for NPDES 19-01NPDES 19-01
1201/21/2020Joint Unopposed 1st To Dismiss
1101/13/2020Joint 3rd Status Report
912/09/2019Joint Status Report and Motion Requesting Further Stay of Proceedings
711/01/2019Joint Status Report
508/15/2019Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings
308/05/2019Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions
207/26/2019Request for Replacement of Attachment 6 of the Petition for Review
107/22/2019Petitioner Hecla Limited Lucky Friday Mine Petition for Review
407/22/2019Order Granting Replacement of Petition Attachment
607/22/2019Order Granting Joint Motion for Stay of Proceedings
807/22/2019Order Extending Stay
1007/22/2019Second Order Extending Stay
1307/22/2019Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 19-02NPDES 19-02
509/27/2019EPA Reguon 10 Motion for Voluntary Remand
308/19/2019EPA Region 10 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response Brief
208/12/2019Notification of Stayed Permit Conditions
107/25/2019Petitioner City of Nezperce Petition for Review
407/25/2019Order Granting Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Response
607/25/2019Order Granting Unopposed Motion for Voluntary Remand and Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 19-03NPDES 19-03
9Order Scheduling Oral Argument
1803/20/2020February 20 2020 Oral Argument Transcript
1701/16/2020Permit Issuer Notice Regarding Oral Argument
1601/10/2020Respondent EPA's Surreply
1401/06/2020Permit Issuer EPA Motion for Leave to File surreply
1312/27/2019Petitioner Notice Ltr to EAB re Corrected Word Limitation
1212/23/2019Corrected Reply Brief
1112/23/2019Petitioner Reply Brief
1012/20/2019City of Lowell's Notice Regarding Oral Argument
812/10/2019Permit Issuer Notice Certified Index to the Administrative Record
712/10/2019Permit Issuer Rspondent EPA Region 1 Response to the Petition for ReviewResponse Brief
612/10/2019Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1 Cover Letter
512/10/2019Joint Filing -- EPA & City of Lowell Consent to Service VIA Electronic Mail
311/19/2019Permit Issuer EPA Motion for Extension of Time
211/08/2019Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions
110/24/2019City of Lowell Massachusetts Petitioner Petition for Review
410/24/2019Order Granting Extension of Time
1510/24/2019Order Granting Surreply
1910/24/2019Order Denying Review
Hide details for NPDES 19-04NPDES 19-04
1304/27/2020City of Haverhill Massachusetts Assented to Request for Dismissal of Petition
1104/07/2020Joint Status Report Notice of Partial Withdrawal and Fourth Motion to Stay the Proceedings
1004/07/2020Permit Issuer Notice Cover Letter for Status Report, Partial Withdrawal, and Fourth Motion to Stay
802/21/2020Joint Status Report and Third Motion to Stay the Proceedings
601/07/2020Joint Unopposed 2nd For an Extension of Time
501/07/2020Permit Issuer Notice Cover Letter for Status Report and Motion
311/14/2019Joint Motion To Stay The Proceedings
211/08/2019Permit Issuer Notice Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions
110/25/2019City of Haverhill Petition for Review
410/25/2019Order Granting Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
710/25/2019Order Granting Second Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
910/25/2019Order Granting Third Joint Motion to Stay the Proceedings
1210/25/2019Order Granting Fourth Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
1410/25/2019Order Granting Motion and Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 19-05NPDES 19-05
1104/03/2020Greater Lawrence Sanitary District Assented to Request for Dismissal of Petition
902/21/2020Joint Status Report and Third Motion to Stay the Proceedings
701/07/2020Joint Unopposed 2nd For an Extension of Time
601/07/2020Permit Issuer Notice Cover Letter for Status Report and Motion
411/14/2019Joint Motion To Stay The Proceedings
311/08/2019Notice of Uncontested and Severable Permit Conditions
210/29/2019Petitioner Notice Errata Sheet
510/25/2019Order Granting Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
810/25/2019Order Granting Second Motion to Stay Proceedings
1010/25/2019Order Granting Third Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
1210/25/2019Order Granting Petitioner Motion and Dismissing Petition for Review
110/25/2019Greater Lawrence Sanitary District Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 19-06NPDES 19-06
31Order Scheduling Oral Argument and Directing Parties to File Notice of Participation
3809/30/2020September 3 2020 Oral Argument Transcript
3708/19/2020Region 9 Response to Order Requiring Documents To Be Included In The Administrative Record
3507/31/2020Amicus Navajo Transitional Energy Company LLC Notice Regarding Oral Argument
3407/31/2020Region 9 Notice Regarding Oral Argument
3307/31/2020Arizona Public Service Company's Notice Regarding Oral Argument
3207/29/2020Petitioner Notice Regarding Oral Argumement
3002/12/2020Permittee Reply Brief
2801/28/2020Permittee Arizona Public Service Company Reply to Petitioners Opposition to Motion for Leave to File a Surreply or in the Alternative to Strike all New Issues and Arguments in Petitioners Reply
2701/24/2020Petitioner Response Brief
2601/17/2020Permittee Opposed 1st For Leave to File A Surreply or in the Alternative to Strike all New Issues and Arguments in Petitioners Reply
2501/16/2020Permit Issuer Notice Revised Certified Administrative Record Index
2401/13/2020Petitioner Consolidated Reply Brief to EPA and APS Response Briefs and to NTEC Amicus Brief
2201/02/2020Navajo Transitional Energy Company LLC Amicus Brief
2101/02/2020Amicus Notice of Appearance
1912/30/2019Petitioner Unopposed Motion to Strike Administrative Record Document Number 30
1812/30/2019Petitioner Unopposed 1st For an Extension of Time
1712/30/2019Received via Fax Petitioners Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to File Rely Brief
1612/23/2019Permit Issuer Corrected Table of Attachments
1412/20/2019Corrected Certificate of Service
1312/19/2019Attachment 8 to APS Response to Petition for Review
1212/18/2019Permit Issuer Certificate of Service
1112/18/2019Permit Issuer Response Brief
1012/18/2019Permit Issuer Unopposed 1st Other
912/18/2019Attachments 20 through 26 for APS Response to Petition for Review
812/18/2019Arizona Public Service Company's Response to Petition for Review
611/25/2019Permit Issuer Notice of Stay
511/18/2019Notice of Appearance By Arizona Public Service Company
311/15/2019Motion for Leave to Exceed Word Limitation
111/01/2019Dine Citizens Against Ruining the Environment, San Juan Citizen Alliance, Amigos Bravos, Center for Biological Diversity and Sierra Club Petition for Review
211/01/2019Order Requiring Submission of Revised Petition of Motion for Leave to Exceed Word Limitation
411/01/2019Order Granting Motion to Exceed Word Limit and Establishing Deadline for Responsive Materials
1511/01/2019Order Granting Motion to Exceed Word Limit
2011/01/2019Order Granting Extension of Time to File Reply Brief
2311/01/2019Order Granting Motion to Strike and Notice of Service by E-mail
2911/01/2019Order Granting Motion For Leave To File Surreply
3611/01/2019Order Requiring Documents to be Included in the Administrative Record
3911/01/2019Order Denying Review
4011/01/2019Dine' Citizens Against Ruining the Env't v. EPA
Hide details for NPDES 19-07NPDES 19-07
201/16/2020Region IX Motion to Dismiss
112/20/2019Petitioner Petition for Review
312/20/2019Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 20-01NPDES 20-01
22Order Granting Extension of Time, Scheduling Oral Argument, and Directing Parties to Provide Notice of Participation
27Order Granting Unopposed Motion for Schedule Modification
3211/13/2020Oral Argument Transcript held on October 8, 2020
3109/11/2020Petitioner Notice Regarding Oral Argument
3009/11/2020Petitioner Reply Brief
2909/10/2020Region 9 Notice Regarding Oral Argument
2808/20/2020Notice of Appearance of Richard S. Davis and Andrew C. Silton
2608/14/2020San Francisco's Unopposed Motion for Schedule Modification
2407/30/2020San Francisco's Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time
2307/23/2020Permit Issuer Region 9 Response to San Francisco Supplement to Petition for Review
2006/30/2020Joint Motion for Extension of Time
2106/30/2020Supplement to Petition for Review of City and County of San Francisco's Oceanside Wastewater Treatment Plants NPDES Permit Issued by EPA Region 9
1906/22/2020Permit Issuer Notice of Errata June 22, 2020
1706/15/2020City and County of San Francisco Reply in Support of Motion for Partial Reconsideration or in the Alternative Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review
1606/08/2020Permit Issuer Region 9 Response to Motion for Partial Reconsideration or, in the Alternative, Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review
1505/21/2020City and County of San Francisco Motion for Partial Reconsideration or in the Alternative Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review
1304/16/2020City and County of San Francisco Reply in Support of Motion to Stay Contested Permit Conditions Pending Appeal or in the Alternative Motion to Remand Notice of Stayed Contested Permit Conditions and Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review
1204/15/2020City and County of San Francisco Reply Brief in Support of Petition for Review of San Francisco Oceanside Wastewater Treatment Plants NPDES Permit Issued by EPA Region 9
1104/15/2020Brief of Amici Curiae National Association of Clean Water Agencies and California Association of Sanitation Ageencies in Support of Petitioner
903/18/2020Petitioner Unopposed Motion For Extension of Time
803/16/2020Permit Issuer Region 9 Response to Motion to Stay Contested Permit Conditiions Pending Appeal or in the Alternative Motion to Remand Notice of Stayed Contested Permit Conditions and Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review
702/28/2020Permit Issuer Notice Certified Administrative Record Index
602/28/2020EPA Region 9 Response to San Francisco Petition for Review of Oceanside NPDES Permit
502/28/2020City and County of San Francisco Motion to Stay Contested Permit Conditions Pending Appeal or in the Alternative Motion to Remand Notice of Stayed Contested Permit Conditions and Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review
302/10/2020Joint Motion for Extension of Time
202/07/2020Permit Issuer Notice of Stay
101/13/2020Petitioner City and County of San Francisco Petition for Review
401/13/2020Order Granting Extension of Time
1001/13/2020Order Granting Extension of Time
1401/13/2020Order Denying Motion to Stay or, in the Alternative, to Remand Notice of Stayed Contested Permit Conditions and Denying Motion for Leave to Amend Petition for Review
1801/13/2020Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration and Granting Petitioner Leave to Supplement Petition for Review with Limitations
2501/13/2020Order Granting Extension of Time to File Reply in Support of Supplement to Petition
3301/13/2020Order Denying Review
3401/13/2020City and County of San Francisco v. EPA
Hide details for NPDES 20-02NPDES 20-02
603/16/2020EPA Reply to Incorporated County of Los Alamos Response to Motion to Dismiss For Lack of Jurisdiction or in the Alternative Motion for Extension of Time
503/05/2020Incorporated County of Los Alamos New Mexico Response to Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction or in the Alternative Motion for Extension of Time
403/02/2020Petitioner Notice of Appearance
202/14/2020Permit Issuer Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction, or in the Alternative Motion for Extension of Time
101/17/2020Petitioner Petition for Review
301/17/2020Scheduling Order
701/17/2020Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 20-03NPDES 20-03
1411/23/2020HOLTEC Decommissioning International LLC and HOLTEC Pilgrim LLC Assented to Request for Dismissal of Petition
1210/15/2020Joint 4th Status Report and Motion to Extend Stay
1109/08/2020Joint 3rd Status Report
907/17/2020Joint Motion to Extend Stay of Proceedings
807/08/2020Motion For Withdrawal of Entergy As Petitioner
706/30/2020Motion for Partial Withdrawal of Petition for Review
606/29/2020Joint 2nd Status Report
405/12/2020Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions
203/26/2020Joint Motion For Stay of the Proceedings
103/06/2020Petitioner Petition for Review
303/06/2020Order Granting Joint Motion to Stay Proceedings
1003/06/2020Order Granting Motion for Partial Withdrawal of Petition Motion For Withdrawal of Entergy as Petitioner and Joint Motion for Extension of Stay
1303/06/2020Order Granting Joint Motion for Second Extension of Stay
1503/06/2020Order Dismissing Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 20-04NPDES 20-04
505/21/2020Permit Issuer Region 9 Motion to Dismiss
405/21/2020Permit Issuer Notice of Partial Withdrawal of Permit and Notice of Effective Date
304/27/2020Permittee Petition for Review of Starkist Samoa Co. NPDES AS0000019
604/27/2020Order Dismissing Petition for Review as Moot
103/18/2020Motion with Consent for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
203/18/2020Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time to File Petition for Review
Hide details for NPDES 20-05NPDES 20-05
25Order Scheduling Oral Argument and Directing Parties to File Notice of Participation
4306/16/2021EPA Region 1 Reply to Petitioners’ Responses to EPA’s Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Re Calendaring of Oral Argument
4206/11/2021Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Recalendaring of Oral Argument NPDES Appeals N. 20-05 20-06
4106/11/2021Response of Petitioners Sierra Club and Conservation Law Foundation to EPA Region 1 Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Recalendaring of Oral Argument NPDES Appeal No 20 05
4006/04/2021EPA Region 1 Motion for Voluntary Remand and Partial Re Calendaring for Oral Argument Granite Shore Power Merrimack LLC NPDES Appeals Nos 20-05 and 20-06
3804/26/2021EPA Region 1 Reply to GSP Merrimack LLC Response to the Region Motion for Further Abeyance
3604/21/2021Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Further Abeyance
3404/14/2021Permit Issuer EPA Region 1 Motion for Further Abeyance
3202/08/2021Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Continuance of the Date fo Oral Argument and Abeyance
3002/03/2021Permit Issuer Region 1 Motion for Continuance of the Date for Oral Argument and Abeyance
2901/11/2021Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1's Notice of Participation
2801/11/2021Permittee Notice of Participation
2701/08/2021Petitioner Notice of Participation
2412/04/2020Region 1 Reply to Petitioners' Opposition to the Region's Motion to Strike Attachments 36 Through 41 to the Petition for Reviewr
2312/04/2020Region 1 Surreply
2111/20/2020Permit Issuer Motion for Leave to File Surreply
2011/09/2020Petitioners' Opposition to EPA Region 1 Motion to Strike
1911/09/2020Petitioner Reply Brief
1710/21/2020Petitioner Unopposed 2nd For an Extension of Time
1610/09/2020Amicus Brief of the N.H. Department of Environmental Services
1409/30/2020Consent Motion for Extension of time to Respond to Motion to Strike and to Reply to Response
1309/25/2020Permittee Brief
1209/25/2020Permit Issuer EPA Region 1 Motion to Strike Petitioners Attachments 36-41 to the Petition for Review
1109/25/2020Permit Issuer Response Brief
1009/25/2020Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1 Cover Letter
909/25/2020Permit Issuer Notice EPA Region 1 Certified Administrative Record Index
809/25/2020Permit Issuer Notice Certified Index to the Administrative Record
709/01/2020Permit Issuer Notice of Uncontested and Severable Conditions
608/11/2020Permittee Notice of Appearance by GSP Merrimack LLC
507/27/2020Petition for Review by Sierra Club Conservation Law Foundation Attachments Continued
407/27/2020Petition for Review by Sierra Club Conservation Law Foundation
1507/27/2020Order Granting Consent Motion for Extension of time to Respond to Motion to Strike and to Reply to Response
1807/27/2020Order Granting Consent Motion for Extensions of Time to Reply to Responses to Petition for Review and to Respond to Motion to Strike and to Reply to Response
2207/27/2020Order Granting Motion for Leave to File surreply
2607/27/2020Corrected Order Scheduling Oral Argument and Directing Parties to File Notice of Participation
3107/27/2020Order Setting Deadline For Response To Motion For Continuance Of Oral Argument Date
3307/27/2020Order Granting Motion For Continuance of OralArgument Date and Abeyance
3507/27/2020Order Setting Deadline for Response to Motion for Further Abeyance
3707/27/2020Order Setting Deadline for Reply to Response On Motion for Further Abeyance
3907/27/2020Order Granting in Part Motion for Continuance of Abeyance
4407/27/2020Remand Order GSP Merrimack LLC NPDES Appeal Nos. 20-05 and 20-06
206/15/2020Consent Motion Regarding Briefing Schedule and Word Limits for Petition for Review, Response, and Replies
106/12/2020Consent Motion Regarding Briefing Schedule and Word Limits for Petition for Review, Response, and Replies
306/12/2020Order Granting Consent Motion for Extension of Time and Increase Word Limits and Notifying the Parties of Electronic Service
Hide details for NPDES 20-06NPDES 20-06
12Order Scheduling Oral Argument and Directing Parties to File Notice of Participation
2806/16/2021EPA Region 1 Reply to Petitioners’ Responses to EPA’s Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Re-Calendaring of Oral Argument,
2706/11/2021Permittee GSP Merrimack LLC Response to EPA Motion for Partial Voluntary Remand and Partial Recalendaring of Oral Argument NPDES Appeals No 20-05 20-06
2606/04/2021EPA Region 1 Motion for Voluntary Remand and Partial Re Calendaring of Oral Argument Granite Shore Power Merrimack LLC NPDES Appeals Nos 20-05 and 20-06

Click for full-text searchSearch this collection

Environmental Appeals Board

  • EAB Home Page
  • EAB Dockets & Decisions
  • Federal Court Review
  • Rules & Standing Orders Governing Appeals
  • Alternative Dispute Resolution
  • Electronic Filing
  • Upcoming Oral Arguments
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • General Information
Contact Us
Contact Us to ask a question, provide feedback, or report a problem.Last updated on October 15, 2026
United States Environmental Protection Agency

Discover.

  • Accessibility Statement
  • Budget & Performance
  • Contracting
  • EPA www Web Snapshots
  • Grants
  • No FEAR Act Data
  • Privacy
  • Privacy and Security Notice

Connect.

  • Data
  • Inspector General
  • Jobs
  • Newsroom
  • Open Government
  • Regulations.gov
  • Subscribe
  • USA.gov
  • White House

Ask.

  • Contact EPA
  • EPA Disclaimers
  • Hotlines
  • FOIA Requests
  • Frequent Questions

Follow.

Last updated on October 15, 2026