US EPA Environmental Appeals Board



Case Index for PSD 08-02 - Northern Michigan University

05/06/2024 09:06:13 AM


Filing #: 1 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review and Request for Oral Argument

Filing #: 1.1 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 1

Filing #: 1.2 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 2

Filing #: 1.3 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 3

Filing #: 1.4 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 4

Filing #: 1.5 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 5

Filing #: 1.6 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 6

Filing #: 1.7 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 7

Filing #: 1.8 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 8

Filing #: 1.9 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 9

Filing #: 2.10 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 10

Filing #: 2.20 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 11

Filing #: 2.30 - 06/13/2008 - Sierra Club's Petition for Review Exhibit 12

Filing #: 2.40 - 06/16/2008 - Letter to Steven Chester, Director, DEQ, requesting Response to the Petition for Review

Filing #: 3 - 06/16/2008 - Concurrences --- Letter to Steven Chester, Director, DEQ, Requestiong Response to the Petition for Review (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 4 - 07/08/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Respondent's Motion for Extension of Time to File a Response to the Merits of the Petition for Review

Filing #: 5 - 07/09/2008 - Original -- State of Michigan, Assistant Attorney General, Respondent's Motion for Extension of Time to File a Response to the Merits of the Petition (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 6 - 07/10/2008 - Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time to File Response

Filing #: 7 - 07/10/2008 - Facsimile Cover Sheet -- David C. Bender et al. -- Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time to File Response

Filing #: 8 - 08/05/2008 - Fax -- Response of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality

Filing #: 9 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibits 9 & 10

Filing #: 10 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 8 part 4

Filing #: 11 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 8 part 3

Filing #: 12 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 8 part 2

Filing #: 13 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 7

Filing #: 14 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibits 5 and 6

Filing #: 15 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 4 part 2

Filing #: 16 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 4 part 1

Filing #: 17 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 3

Filing #: 18 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit - Part 5

Filing #: 19 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 2 Part 4

Filing #: 20 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 2 Part 3

Filing #: 21 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit Part 2

Filing #: 22 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 2 Part 2

Filing #: 23 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 2 Part 1

Filing #: 24 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 1

Filing #: 25 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit Part 2

Filing #: 26 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality

Filing #: 27 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Cover Letter to Clerk of the Court and Proof of Service.

Filing #: 28 - 08/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Exhibit 8 Part 1

Filing #: 29 - 08/06/2008 - Original -- Response of th Michigan Department of Environmental Quality a Certified Index of the Administrative Record and Proof of Service (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 30 - 08/13/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club Notice of Motion of Petitioner for Leave to File Reply

Filing #: 31 - 08/14/2008 - Order Granting Motion for Leave to File A Reply

Filing #: 32 - 08/14/2008 - Facsimile Cover Sheet to Bruce Nilles, David Bender and Neil Gordon et al -- Order Granting Motion for Leave to File A Reply

Filing #: 33 - 08/14/2008 - Original -- Sierra Club's Notice of Motion of Petitioner for Leave to File Reply (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 34 - 08/21/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief

Filing #: 35 - 08/21/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Petitioner's Reply Brief Exhibit 13

Filing #: 36 - 08/22/2008 - Original -- Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 37 - 08/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief Exhibit 14

Filing #: 38 - 08/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief Exhibit 15

Filing #: 39 - 08/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief Exhibit 16

Filing #: 40 - 08/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief Exhibit 17

Filing #: 41 - 08/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief Exhibit 18

Filing #: 42 - 08/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief Exhibit 19

Filing #: 43 - 08/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief Exhibit 20

Filing #: 44 - 08/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club, Petitioner's Reply Brief Exhibit 21

Filing #: 45 - 09/05/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Northern Michigan University Motion for Leave to Intervene

Filing #: 46 - 09/05/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Northern Michigan University Motion for Leave to Intervene Appearance

Filing #: 47 - 09/05/2008 - Original -- Northern Michigan University Motion for Leave to Intervene and Appearance (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 48 - 09/08/2008 - Order Granting Motion to Intervene

Filing #: 49 - 09/08/2008 - Facsimile Cover Sheet to David Bender, Bruce Nilles, Neil Gordon, Kevin Finto and James Rubin et al -- Order Granting Motion to Intervene

Filing #: 50 - 09/10/2008 - Received via Facsimile -- Addendum to Application No. 06-07 to Update S02 Emission Limited Northern Michigan University -- Ripley Heating Plant

Filing #: 51 - 09/17/2008 - Order Scheduling Oral Argument

Filing #: 52 - 09/17/2008 - Facsimile Cover Sheet -- David Bender et al. -- Order Scheduling Oral Argument

Filing #: 53 - 09/19/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Notice of Counsel Who will Present Oral Argument on Behalf of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality

Filing #: 54 - 09/23/2008 - Original -- Notice of Counsel Who will Present Oral Argument on Behalf of the Michigan Department of Environmental Quality

Filing #: 55 - 09/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Response to Petition

Filing #: 55.1 - 09/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Response to Petition - Attachment A

Filing #: 55.2 - 09/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Response to Petition - Attachment B

Filing #: 55.3 - 09/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Response to Petition - Attachment C

Filing #: 55.4 - 09/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Response to Petition - Attachment C

Filing #: 55.5 - 09/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Response to Petition - Attachment D

Filing #: 55.6 - 09/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Response to Petition - Attachment E

Filing #: 55.7 - 09/22/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Response to Petition - Attachment F

Filing #: 56 - 09/22/2008 - Original -- Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Response to Petition

Filing #: 57 - 09/23/2008 - Original -- Corrected Version of Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief In Response to Petition

Filing #: 57.1 - 09/23/2008 - Corrected Version of Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief In Response to Petition -- Attachment A

Filing #: 57.2 - 09/23/2008 - Corrected Version of Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief In Response to Petition -- Attachment B

Filing #: 57.3 - 09/23/2008 - Corrected Version of Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief In Response to Petition -- Attachment C

Filing #: 57.4 - 09/23/2008 - Corrected Version of Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief In Response to Petition -- Attachment D

Filing #: 57.5 - 09/23/2008 - Corrected Version of Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief In Response to Petition -- Attachment E

Filing #: 57.6 - 09/23/2008 - Corrected Version of Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief In Response to Petition -- Attachment F

Filing #: 57.7 - 09/23/2008 - Corrected Version of Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief In Response to Petition -- Attachment G

Filing #: 58 - 09/23/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Corrected Version of Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief In Response to Petition

Filing #: 59 - 10/02/2008 - Order Regarding Oral Argument

Filing #: 60 - 10/02/2008 - Facsimile Cover Sheet to David C. Bender et al -- Order Regarding Oral Argument

Filing #: 62 - 10/06/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Oral Argument Notice

Filing #: 63 - 10/06/2008 - Fax -- Oral Argument Notice (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 64 - 10/06/2008 - Original -- Sierra Club's Reply to Intervenor Northern Michigan University's Brief in Reponse to Petition

Filing #: 65 - 10/08/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club's Notice of Appearance for Oral Argument

Filing #: 66 - 10/10/2008 - Order

Filing #: 67 - 10/10/2008 - Facsimile Cover Sheet to David Bender, Bruce Nilles, Kevin Finto, James Rubin and Neil Gordon et al -- Order

Filing #: 68 - 10/09/2008 - Original -- Petitioner's Notice of Appearance for Oral Argument (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 69 - 10/10/2008 - Fax -- Notice of Motion of Petitioner to Reconsider and for Leave to Extend Time to File Reply

Filing #: 70 - 10/14/2008 - Original -- Notice of Motion of Petitioner to Reconisder and for Leave to Extend Time to File Reply (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 71 - 10/14/2008 - Original -- Hunton & Williams LLP notify Board who is presenting oral argument on 10/22/2008 (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 72 - 10/10/2008 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Sierra Club's Notice of Motion of Petitioner to Reconsider and for Leave to Exdtend time to File Reply

Filing #: 73 - 10/15/2008 - Order Accepting Late-Filed Reply

Filing #: 74 - 10/16/2008 - Facsimile Cover Sheet -- David Bender et al. -- Order Accepting Late-Filed Reply

Filing #: 75 - 10/16/2008 - Petitioner's Notice of Appearance for Oral Argument - (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 76 - 11/03/2008 - Transcript from Oral Argument on October 22, 2008 (Pages 1 -- 25)

Filing #: 76.1 - 11/03/2008 - Transcript from Oral Argument on October 22, 2008 (Pages 26 -- 50)

Filing #: 76.2 - 11/03/2008 - Transcript from Oral Argument on October 22, 2008 (Pages 51 -- 75)

Filing #: 76.3 - 11/03/2008 - Transcript from Oral Argument on October 22, 2008 (Pages 76 --100)

Filing #: 76.4 - 11/03/2008 - Transcript from Oral Argument on October 22, 2008 (Pages 101 --124)

Filing #: 77 - 10/22/2008 - Transcript from Oral Argument held October 22, 2008

Filing #: 78 - 02/18/2009 - Order Denying Review in Part and Remanding in Part

Filing #: 79 - 03/05/2009 - Domestic Return Receipt (HARD COPY ONLY)

Filing #: 80 - 05/20/2009 - Received via CDX Electronic -- Letter Informing the EAB That, Pursuant To A Request By Northern Michigan University, the MDEQ Has Voiced Permit Number 60-07

Filing #: 81 - 05/21/2009 - Original -- Letter Informing EAB that the MDEQ Has Voided Permit Number 60-07 (HARD COPY ONLY)